Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
 | Online Publication Date: 21 Feb 2006
Union Responses to Nafta in the US and Canada: Explaining Intra- and International Variation
Union Responses to Nafta in the US and Canada: Explaining Intra- and International Variation
and
Page Range: 163 – 184
In this article we ask why some unions in Canada and the United States were more actively opposed to NAFTA than others, and why these "activist" unions differed in the strategies that they adopted for fighting NAFTA and in the alternatives that they offered to it. We ask the same questions about differences between the U.S. and Canadian labor movements as embodied in the rhetoric and behavior of their central federations. We distinguish four union "types" on two dimensions: the inclusiveness of union leaders' collective identity (i.e., the kinds of workers that the union actively seeks to organize), and the radicalness of union leaders' moral economy (i.e., how critical the union is of the status quo political economy). We hypothesize that differences in union type, so defined, explain a significant part of the variation in the levels of union activism against NAFTA in both countries, as well as differences in strategies of opposition. Differences in the relative strength of union types is also hypothesized to be an important factor explaining strategic differences between the two national labor federations. We use statistical analysis of survey data, as well as qualitative analysis of institutional variables, to operationalize and assess these hypotheses. We find considerable support for them.
Herling, John. 1972. Right to Challenge: People, and Power in the Steelworkers' Union.
Shister, Joseph. 1967. "The Direction of Unionism, 1947-1967: Thrust of Drift?" Industrial, and Labor Relations Review 20, 4 (July): 578-601.
Silver, Marc L. 1986. Under Construction: Work, and Alienation in the Building Trades. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Abella, Irving. 1973. Nationalism, Communism, and Canadian Labour. Toronto, Ont.: University of Toronto Press.
ACN. 1993. "Setting a People's Agenda: Free Trade Alternatives." Action Dossier 39(Autumn).
Yates, Charlotte. 1992. "North American Autoworkers' Response to Restructuring." Pp. 111-145 in Bargaining for Change: Union Politics in North America, and Europe, Miriam Golden, and Jonas Pontusson, eds. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Kazis, J., and Richard Grossman. 1982. Fear at Work: Job Blackmail, Labor, and the Environment. New York: Pilgrim Press.
Kealey, Gregory S., and Bryan D. Palmer. 1987. Dreaming of What Might Be: The Knights of Labour in Ontario, 1880-1900. New Hogtown Press.
Kessler-Harris, Alice. 1987. "Trade Unions Mirror Society in Conflict Between Collectivism, and Individualism," Monthly Labor Review 110(8): 32-35.
Kimeldorf, Howard. 1988. Reds or Rackets? The Making of Radical, and Conservative Unions on the Waterfront. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Klandermans, Bert. 1988. "Union Action, and the Free-Rider Dilemma." in Louis Kriesberg, and Bronislaw Misztal, eds. Research in Social Movements, Conflicts, and Change. Volume 10. Greenwich, Conn.: JAI Press.
LaBotz, Dan. 1990. Rank-and-File Rebellion: Teamsters for a Democratic Union. London: Verso.
Kozura, Michael. 1996. "We Stood Our Own Ground: Anthracite Miners, and the Expropriation of Corporate Property, 1930-1941." Pp. 199-237 in We Are All Leaders: The Alternative Unionism of the Early 1930s, S. Lynd, ed. Urbana: University of Illinois Press
LaLuz, Jose. 1991. "Creating a Culture of Organizing: ACTWU's Education for Empowerment." Labor Research Review 10, 1 (Spring): 61-68.
Leier, Mark. 1990. Where the Fraser River Flows: the IWW in BC. Vancouver: New Star.
Lembcke, Jerry. 1988. Capitalist Development, and Class Capacities: Marxist Theory, and Union Organization. New York: Greenwood Press.
Lichtenstein, Nelson. 1995. The Most Dangerous Man in Detroit: Walter Reuther, and the Fate of American Labor. New York: Basic Books.
Moody, Kim. 1997a. Workers in a Lean World: Unions in International Economy. New York: Verso.
Lipset, Seymour Martin. 1986. "North American Unions: A Comparative Perspective." Pp. 421-54 in Unions in Transition, S.M. Lipset, ed. San Francisco: Institute for Contemporary Study,.
Lipset, Seymour Martin. 1991. Continental Divide: The Values, and Institutions of the United States, and Canada. London: Routledge.
Lipset, Seymour Martin. 1996. American Exceptionalism: A Double-edged Sword. New York: W.W. Norton.
Welsh, Robert W. 1997. "Building, and Changing: A New Beginning at the AFL-CIO." Pp. 73-84 in Audacious Democracy, Steven Fraser, and Joshua B. Freeman, eds. New York: Houghton Mifflin Co.
Yates, Charlotte. 1993. From Plant to Politics: The Autoworkers Union in Postwar Canada. Temple University Press.
Lipset, Seymour Martin. 1960. "The Political Process in Trade Unions: A Theoretical Statement." in Labor, and Trade Unionism, edited by Walter Galenson, and S.M. Lipset. Wiley.
Lipset, Seymour Martin. 1983. "Radicalism or Reformism." American Political Science Review 77(March 1983).
Lipsig-Mummé, Carla. 1987. "The Web of Dependence: Quebec Unions in Politics Before 1976," Pp. 133-156. in Quebec Since 1945: Selected Readings, Michael Behiels, ed. Toronto: Copp Clark Pitman, Ltd.
Logan, Harold A. 1928. The History of Trade-Union Organization in Canada. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Marks, Gary. 1989. Unions in Politics: Britain, Germany, and the United States in the Nineteenth, and Early Twentieth Centuries. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
McCormack, Ross. 1985. "Wobblies, and Blanketstiffs: The Constituency of the IWW in Western Canada." Pp. 101-114 in Lectures in Canadian Labour, and Working-Class History, edited by W.J.C. Cherwinski, and Greg S. Kealey. Committee on Canadian Labour History, and New Hogtown Press.
Michels, Robert. 1962. Political Parties. Crowell-Collier.
Midwest Center for Labor Research. 1991. "An Organizing Model of Unionism." Labor Research Review 10,1(Spring)
Midwest Center for Labor Research. 1991/1992. "Let's Get Moving Organizing in the 90s." Labor Research Review 10,2(Fall/Winter).
Milton, David. 1982. The Politics of U.S. Labor: From the Great Depression to the New Deal. New York: Monthly Review Press.
Morton, Desmond. 1990. Working People, Second ed. Toronto: Summerhill Press.
Moody, Kim. 1988. An Injury to All: the Decline of American Unionism. New York: Verso.
Moody, Kim. 1997b. "American Labor: A Movement Again?" Monthly Review 49(July-August): 63-79.
Pontusson, Jonas. 1992. The Limits of Social Democracy: Investment Politics in Sweden. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Rajala, Richard A. 1996. "A Dandy Bunch of Wobblies: Pacific Northwest Loggers, and the IWW, 1900-1930." Labor History 37(2 (Spring)):205-234.
Robinson, Ian. 1993a. "American Union Growth in the 1930s, and 1940s: Competing Explanations, and Their Implications." Business, and the Contemporary World 5(1): 99-115.
Robinson, Ian. 1994. "The Canadian Labour Movement Against "Free Trade": An Assessment of Strategies, and Outcomes." in Conference on Labor, Free Trade, and Economic Integration in the Americas: National Labor Union Responses to a Transnational World.
Robinson, Ian. 1995. "Democratic Critiques of the Institutions, and Processes of Neoliberal Economic Integration: An Assessment." Cahiers de recherche sociologique 24: 161-184.
Robinson, Ian. 1993b. "Economistic Unionism in Crisis: The Origins, Consequences, and Prospects of Divergence in Labour-Movement Characteristics," Pp. 19-47. in The Challenge of Restructuring: North American Labor Movements Respond, Jane Jenson, and Rianne Mahon, eds. Philadelphia: Temple University Press
Rogowski, Ronald. 1989. Commerce, and Coalitions: How Trade Affects Domestic Political Alignments. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Romer, Sam. 1962. The International Brotherhood of Teamsters: Its Government, and Structure. New York: John Wiley, and Sons.
Salerno, Salvatore. 1989. Red November, Black November: Culture, and Community in the IWW. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Schatz, Ronald W. 1983. The Electrical Workers: A History of Labor at General Electric, and Westinghouse, 1923-60. Urbana, IL:University of Illinois Press.
Schatz, Ronald W. 1996. "From Commons to Dunlop: Rethinking the Field, and Theory of Industrial Relations." Pp. 87-112 in Industrial Democracy in America: The Ambiguous Promise, Nelson Lichtenstein, and Howell John Harris, eds. New York: Woodrow Wilson Center Press, and Cambridge University Press.
Scipes, Kim. 1992. "Understanding New Labor Movements in the Third World: The Emergence of Social Movement Unionism," Critical Sociology 19(2):81-101.
Scipes, Kim. 1996. KMU: Building Genuine Trade Unionism in the Philippines, 1980-1994. Quezon City, Philippines: New Day Publishers.
Banks, Andy. 1991/92. "The Power, and Promise of Community Unionism." Labor Research Review 10, 2(Fall/Winter): 17-32.
Bercuson, David Jay. 1978. Fools, and Wise Men: The Rise, and Fall of the One Big Union. Toronto/New York: McGraw-Hill Ryerson.
Bleyer, Peter. 1997. "Coalitions of Social Movements as Agencies for Social Change: The Action Canada Network." Pp. 134-150. in Organizing Dissent: Contemporary Social Movements in Theory, and Practice, William K. Carroll, ed. Toronto: Garamond Press
Brown, Cliff, and John Brueggeman. 1997. "Mobilizing Interracial Solidarity: Comparison of the 1919, and 1937 Steel Organizing Drives." Mobilization 2(1):47-70.
Carroll, William K., and R.S. Ratner. 1995. "Old Unions, and New Social Movements," Labour/Le Travail 35(Spring): 195-221.
CLC. 1994. "International Solidarity, and the Global Economy." Policy Statement Convention Theme Document. Toronto: 20th Constitutional Convention of the Canadian Labour Congress.
Collier, Ruth Berins, and David Collier. 1991. Shaping the Political Arena: Critical Junctures, the Labor Movement, and Regime Dynamics in Latin America. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Cowie, Jefferson. 1996. "National Struggles in a Transnational Economy: A Critical Analysis of US Labor's Campaign Against NAFTA." Labor Studies Journal 21(4): 3-32.
Crump, Joe. 1991/92. "The Pressure's On: Organizing without the NLRB." Labor Research Review 10, 2(Fall/Winter): 33-44.
Dreiling, Michael. 1997. "Remapping North American Environmentalism: Contending Visions, and Divergent Practices in the Fight Over NAFTA." Capitalism, Nature, Socialism 8(4): 65-98.
Dubofsky, Melvyn. 1988. We Shall Be All: A History of the Industrial Workers of the World, 2nd ed. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Fraser, Steven. 1991. Labor Will Rule: Sidney Hillman, and the Rise of American Labor. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Freeman, Richard, and James Medoff (eds.). 1984. What Do Unions Do? New York: Basic Books.
Ghilarducci, Teresa. 1988. "The Impact of Internal Union Politics on the 1981 UMWA Strike." Industrial Relations 27:371-84.
Gindin, Sam. 1992. "Breaking Away: The Formation of the Canadian Auto Workers." 29 Studies in Political Economy (Summer).
Gindin, Sam. 1997. "Notes on Labor at the End of the Century: Starting Over?" Monthly Review 49, 3 (July-August):140-157.
Goldfield, Michael. 1987. The Decline of Organized Labor in the United States. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Stepan-Norris, Judith, and Maurice Zeitlin. 1991. "Insurgency, Radicalism, and Democracy in America's Industrial Unions." Institute for Industrial Relations.
Stepan-Norris, Judith, and Maurice Zeitlin. 1996. Talking Union. Urbana, and Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
Thompson, Fred. 1955. The I.W.W.: It's First Fifty Years. Industrial Workers of the World.
Tilly, Charles. 1978. From Mobilization to Revolution. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Voss, Kim. 1993. The Making of American Exceptionalism: The Knights of Labor, and Class Formation in the Nineteenth Century. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Waterman, Peter. 1993. "Social Movement Unionism: A New Model for a New World Order?" Review XVI (Summer).
Wellman, David. 1995. The Union Makes Us Strong: Radical Unionism on the San Francisco Waterfront. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Green, Hardy. 1990. On Strike at Hormel: The Struggle for a Democratic Labor Movement. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Grinspun, Ricardo. 1991. "North American Free Trade Area: A Critical Economic Perspective." Center for Policy Alternatives, Ottawa.
Haydu, Jeffrey. 1988. Between Craft, and Class: Skilled Workers, and Factory Politics in the U.S., and Britain, 1890-1922. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Hirsch, Barry, and John Addison. 1986. The Economic Analysis of Unions. Allen & Unwin.
Hoerr, John. 1988. And the Wolf Finally Came: The Decline of the American Steel Industry. Pittsburgh: University of Pittsburgh Press.
Johnston, Paul. 1994. Success Where Others Fail: Social Movement Unionism, and the Public Workplace. Ithaca, NY: ILR Press.
Seidman, Gay. 1994. Manufacturing Militance: Workers' Movements in Brazil, and South Africa, 1970-1985. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Stepan-Norris, Judith, and Maurice Zeitlin. 1989. "Who Get's the Bird? or, How the Communists Won Power, and Trust in America's Unions: The Relative Autonomy of Intraclass Political Struggles." American Sociological Review 54: 503-23.
Ayres, Jeffrey M. 1996. "Political Process, and Popular Protest: The Mobilization Against Free Trade in Canada." American Journal of Economics, and Sociology 55(4): 473-89.