Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 21 Feb 2006
How Participatory Democracy Became White: Culture and Organizational Choice
How Participatory Democracy Became White: Culture and Organizational Choice
Page Range: 271 – 288
Why do activists choose the organizational forms they do? Social movement scholars have tended to focus on activists' instrumental assessments of organizational forms' costs and benefits or on activists' efforts to balance instrumental calculations with a commitment to ideological consistency. Neither explanation is adequate. Organizational forms, like strategies, tactics, and targets, are often appealing for their symbolic associations, and especially, their association with particular social groups. The article fleshes out this dynamic through a case study of the rise and fall of participatory democracy in the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC). Contrary to standard explanations for SNCC activists' repudiation of consensus-based and nonhierarchical decision making in the mid-1960s, I show that participatory democracy was abandoned when it came to be seen as ideological, oriented to personal self-transformation, and—no coincidence—as white. That was not the case earlier on, when participatory democracy was seen as practical, political, and black, and I account for that shift. Once established, however, participatory democracy's social associations shaped subsequent activist generations' view of the form's strengths and liabilities.
Tarleton, John. 2001. "After Quebec, What Next," New York Indypendent, May 2001, reprinted in
Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee [SNCC]. 1966a. Staff Conference, "Assumptions Made by SNCC", 11 May. SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 3, frames 1053-1058.
Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee [SNCC]. 1967a. Report from the Chairman, Stokely Carmichael, 7 May. SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 3, frames 1129-1132.
Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee [SNCC]. 1967b. Central Committee Meeting Notes, 22 September, SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 72, frames 173-205.
Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee [SNCC]. 1965c. Executive Committee Meeting minutes, April 12-14. SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 3, frames 410-426.
Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee [SNCC]. 1965b. Personal M. to Jim Forman, [Spring]. SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 12, frames 512-513.
Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee [SNCC]. 1965a. Minutes of Steering Committee Meeting, 23 February. SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 34, frames 395-6.
Thelwell, Mike. 1964. "Mississippi's Metaphysical Mystics---A Sect Wrapped Up in a Clique Within a Cult" [November]. Mary E. King Papers, SHSW.
Payne, Charles. 1995. I've Got the Light of Freedom: The Organizing Tradition, and the Mississippi Freedom Struggle. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Forman, James. 1997 (1972). The Making of Black Revolutionaries. Seattle: University of Washington Press.
Lichterman, Paul. 1996. The Search for Political Community: American Activists Reinventing Commitment. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Kitschelt, Herbert. 1986. "Political Opportunity Structures, and Political Protest: Anti-Nuclear Movements in Four Democracies." British Journal of Political Science 16: 57-85.
Mansbridge, Jane. 1983. Beyond Adversary Democracy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
King, Mary. 1987. Freedom Song: A Personal Story of the 1960s Civil Rights Movement. New York: W. Morrow.
Bordt, Rebecca. 1997. The Structure of Women's Nonprofit Organizations. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Breines, Wini. 1989. Community, and Organization in the New Left, 1962-1968: The Great Refusal. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
Rajah, Colin. 2000. "Harsh Reality: Confronting Race on the Student Left," The Activist, fall 2000
Kleinman, Sherryl. 1996. Opposing Ambitions: Gender, and Identity in an Alternative Organization. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Sewell, William H. 1992. "A Theory of Structure: Duality, Agency, and Transformation." American Journal of Sociology 98:1-29.
Polletta, Francesca. 2002. Freedom Is an Endless Meeting: Democracy in American Social Movements. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Sellers, Cleveland with Robert Terrell. 1990. The River of No Return: The Autobiography of a Black Militant, and the Life, and Death of SNCC. Jackson: University Press of Mississippi.
Minkoff, Debra C. 1999. "Bending with the Wind: Strategic Change, and Adaptation by Women's, and Racial Minority Organizations. American Journal of Sociology 104: 1666-1703.
Morgen, Edward. 1991. The 60's Experience: Hard Lessons About Modern America. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Morris, Aldon D. 1984. The Origins of the Civil Rights Movement: Black Communities Organizing for Change. New York: Free Press.
Zald, Mayer N., and John D. McCarthy. 1980. "Social Movement Industries: Competition, and Coopera-tion among Movement Organizations." Research in Social Movements, Conflicts, and Change 3: 1-20.
Zellner, Dorothy. 1992. Personal interview conducted on 4 March, New York City.
Amenta, Edwin, Drew Halfmann, and Michael P. Young. 1999. "The Strategies, and Contexts of Social Protest: Political Mediation, and the Impact of the Townsend Movement in California." Mobilization 4: 1-24.
Armstrong, Elizabeth A. 2002. "Crisis, Collective Creativity, and the Generation of New Organizational Forms: The Transformation of Lesbian/Gay Organizations in San Francisco." Pp. 361-395 in Social Structure, and Organizations Revisited, Marc Ventresca, and Michael Lounsbury, eds. Elsevier Science.
Baker, Elaine Delott. 1964. "Minutes of Staff Meeting in Hattiesburg," 22 December. Elaine Baker DeLott Papers, private collection.
Bond, Julian. 1992. Personal interview conducted 23 March, Washington, D.C.
King, Richard. 1992. Civil Rights, and the Idea of Freedom. New York: Oxford University Press.
Klein, Naomi. 2000. "That Vision Thing." The Nation, July 10.
Larimore-Hall, Daraka. 2000. "Race, Structure, and Vegan Food: A Look at the USAS Conference," The Activist (fall)
Brodkin Sacks, Karen. 1989. "Gender, and Grassroots Leadership." Pp. 77-95 in Women, and the Politics of Empowerment,Ann Bookman, and Sandra Morgen, eds. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Carmichael, Stokely. 1966. "Integration Is Completely Irrelevant to Us: What We Want Is Power for People Who Don't Have It." The Movement, June.
Carson, Clayborne. 1981. In Struggle: SNCC, and the Black Awakening of the 1960s. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Case, John, and Rosemary C.R. Taylor, eds. 1979. Co-Ops, Communes, and Collectives: Experiments in Social Change in the 1960s, and 1970s. New York: Pantheon.
Clecak, Peter. 1981. "The Movement, and Its Legacy." Social Research 48: 521-556.
Conell, Carol, and Kim Voss. 1990. "Formal Organizations, and the Fate of Social Movements: Craft Association, and Class Alliance in the Knights of Labor." American Sociological Review 55: 255-69.
Council of Federated Organizations (COFO). 1964a. Minutes, Fifth District Meeting, November 25. Mary E. King Papers, State Historical Society of Wisconsin (SHSW), Madison, Wisconsin.
Council of Federated Organizations (COFO). 1964b. Canton Valley View Staff Meeting, 2 December. Joann Robinson Papers, SHSW.
Council of Federated Organizations (COFO). 1964c. Minutes of Staff Meeting in Hattiesburg, 22 December, Elaine Delott Baker Papers, private collection.
Downey, Gary L. 1986. "Ideology, and the Clamshell Identity: Organizational Dilemmas in the AntiNuclear Power Movement." Social Problems 33: 357-371.
Epstein, Barbara. 1991. Political Protest, and Cultural Revolution: Nonviolent Direct Action in the 1970s, and 1980s. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Fairclough, Adam. 1985. "The Preachers, and the People: The Origins, and Early Years of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, 1955-1959." Journal of Southern History 52: 403-440.
Freeman, Jo. 1973. "The Tyranny of Structurelessness." In ical Feminism Ann Koedt, Ellen Levine, and Anita Rapone, eds. New York: Quadrangle Books.
Gellatly, Mary Sue. 1965. Mary Sue Gellatly to Mrs. Franz, 6 April, COFO-Shaw Papers, SHSW.
Gitlin, Todd. 1987. The Sixties: Years of Hope, Days of Rage. New York: Bantam.
Hayden, Casey. 1964. "Memorandum on Structure," [November], Casey Hayden Papers, private collection.
Honig, Emily. 1985. "Burning Incense, Pledging Sisterhood." Signs 10: 700-714.
Jones, Charles. 1960. "For the Student Peace Union, Report on The Conference on Nonviolent Action, and the Achievement of Desegregation, The Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee," [October]. Fellowship of Reconciliation Papers, Swarthmore College Peace Collection, series E, box 30.
Kazin, Michael. 1998. The Populist Persuasion: An American History. Ithaca: Cornell University Press.
Kelley, Dick. 1964. "November 28---Dick Kelley." Samuel Walker Papers, SHSW.
King, Mary. 1965a. "Meeting Notes" [February]. Mary E. King Papers, SHSW.
King, Mary. 1965b. Meeting fragment [February]. Mary E. King Papers, SHSW.
King, Mary. 1965c. Mary King to Julian Bond [Spring], SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 36, frame 14.
March, James G., and Johan P. Olsen. 1989. Rediscovering Institutions: The Organizational Basis of Politics. New York: Free Press.
Martinez, Elizabeth (Sutherland). 1995. Personal telephone interview conducted 29 June.
Reed, Adolph, Jr. 1986. "The `Black Revolution', and the Reconstitution of Domination" in Race, Politics, and Culture: Critical Essays on the Radicalism of the 1960s, Adolph Reed, Jr., ed. Westport: Greenwood Press.
Richardson, Judy. 1992. Personal interview conducted 10 December, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Robinson, Betty Garman. 1996. Personal interview conducted 19 June, Baltimore, Maryland.
Robnett, Belinda. 1997. How Long? How Long? African American Women in the Struggle for Civil Rights. New York: Oxford University Press.
Rothschild, Joyce, and J. Allen Whitt. 1986. The Cooperative Workplace: Potentials, and Dilemmas of Organizational Democracy, and Participation. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Rothschild-Whitt, Joyce. 1979. "The Collectivist Organization: An Alternative to Rational-Bureaucratic Models." American Sociological Review 44: 509-27.
Sciacchitano, Katherine. 1998. "The Union is Forever," paper presented at the UCLEA/AFL-CIO Annual Conference, May 1, 1998.
Schwartzbaum, Barbara. 1964. "Hattiesburg Report from Barbara Schwartzbaum," November. SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 66, frame 1270.
Matusow, Allen J. 1969. "From Civil Rights to Black Power: The Case of SNCC: 1960-1966," in Twentieth Century America: Recent Interpretations, Barton J. Bernstein, and Allen J. Matusow, eds. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.
McAdam, Doug. 1983. "Tactical Innovation, and the Pace of Insurgency." American Sociological Review 48: 735-754.
McAdam, Doug. 1988. Freedom Summer. New York: Oxford University Press.
McCammon, Holly J. 2003. "Out of the Parlors, and Into the Streets': The Changing Tactical Repertoire of the U.S. Women's Suffrage Movements." Social Forces 81: 787-818.
Miller, Mike. 1964. "Notes." SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 33, frame 124.
Miller, Mike. 1965. Mike to Cyn, October. SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 24, frames 116-117.
Mills, Nicolaus. 1992. Like a Holy Crusade: Mississippi, 1964---The Turning of the Civil Rights Movement in America. Chicago: Dee
Moses, Bob. 1992. Personal phone interview conducted 9 December.
Moses, Bob. N.D. Interview conducted by Clayborne Carson, Clayborne Carson Papers, Martin Luther King Papers Project, Stanford University.
Nicolaus, Viki, and Martin Nicolaus. 1964. Viki, and Martin to Dear ____, 9 December. Martin, and Viki Nicolaus Papers, SHSW.
Sirianni, Carmen. 1993. "Learning Pluralism: Democracy, and Diversity in Feminist Organizations," Pp. 283-312 in NOMOS XXXV: Democratic Community, John W. Chapman, and Ian Shapiro, eds. New York: New York University Press.
Snow, David A., and Robert D. Benford, 1992. "Master Frames, and Cycles of Protest," in Frontiers in Social Movement Theory, Aldon D. Morris, and Carol McClurg Mueller, eds. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Staggenborg, Suzanne. 1986. "Coalition Work in the Pro-Choice Movement: Organizational, and Environmental Opportunities, and Obstacles." Social Problems 33: 374-390.
Staggenborg, Suzanne. 1989. "Stability, and Innovation in the Women's Movement: A Comparison of Two Movement Organizations." Social Problems 36: 75-92.
Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee [SNCC]. 1960. Minutes of SNCC Meeting, November 25-27. SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 1, frame 780.
Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee [SNCC]. 1964a. Minutes of Staff Meeting, 10 October, handwritten notes by Mary King. Mary E. King Papers, SHSW.
Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee [SNCC]. 1964b. Minutes of Staff Meeting, 11 October, Clayborne Carson Papers, private collection.
Tilly, Charles. 1995. "Contentious Repertoires in Great Britain, 1758-1834." Pp. 15-40 in Cycles, and Repertoires of Collective Action, Mark Traugott, ed. Durham: Duke University Press.
Tilly, Charles. 1999. "Now Where?" Pp. 407-419 in State/Culture: State-Formation after the Cultural Turn,George Steinmetz, ed. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
Treloar, M. 2003. "The Tyranny of Consensus." Clamor 20 (May/June): 38-40.
Turvitz, Nancy, and Gene Turvitz. 1965a. Nancy, and Gene Turvitz to Dear Friends, 4 July. SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 61, frames 1092-1094.
Turvitz, Nancy, and Gene Turvitz. 1965b. Nancy, and Gene Turvitz to Dear Friends, 10-14 July. SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 61, frames 1071-1072.
Warren, Mark R. 2001. Dry Bones Rattling: Community Building to Revitalize American Democracy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Lounsbury, Michael, and Marc Ventresca. 2003. "The New Structuralism in Organizational Theory." Organization 10: 457-80.
Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee [SNCC]. 1966c. Motions, Recommendations, Mandates of Central Committee Meeting, 14-17 May. SNCC Papers (microfilm), reel 3, frames 585-588.
Tarrow, Sidney G. 1998. Power in Movement: Social Movements, and Contentious Politics. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee [SNCC]. 1964c. "Ivanhoe opened the session…" (Minutes of Staff Meeting, Waveland, Mississippi, 7-12 November). Betty Garman Robinson Papers, private collection.
Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee [SNCC]. 1966b. Staff Conference, 8-13 May. James Forman Collection, audiotapes no. 151, 153, and 180, King Library, and Archives, Martin Luther King Jr. Center for Nonviolent Social Change, Atlanta, Georgia.
Stoecker, Randy. 1994. Defending Community: The Struggle for Alternative Redevelopment in CedarRiverside. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Stoper, Emily. 1989. The Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee: The Growth of Radicalism in a Civil Rights Organization. Brooklyn, NY: Carlson.
Minkoff, Debra C. 2002. "The Emergence of Hybrid Organizational Forms: Combining Identity-Based Service Provision, and Political Action." Nonprofit, and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 31: 377-401.
Clemens, Elisabeth S. 1996. "Organizational Form as Frame." Pp. 205-225 in Comparative Perspectives on Social Movements, Doug McAdam, John D. McCarthy, and Mayer N. Zald, eds. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Clemens, Elisabeth S. 1997. The People's Lobby: Organizational Innovation, and the Rise of Interest Group Politics in the United States. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Clemens, Elisabeth S, and James M. Cook. 1999. "Politics, and Institutionalism: Explaining Durability, and Change." Annual Review of Sociology 25: 441-66.
Cobb, Charles. 1965."On Snick/Revolution/and Freedom," [April], Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC) Papers, 1959-1972 (Sanford, NC: Microfilming Corporation of American, 1982), reel 33, frames 269-272.