Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 15 Feb 2007
Explaining The Outcomes of Antisuperstore Movements: A Comparative Analysis of Six Communities
Explaining The Outcomes of Antisuperstore Movements: A Comparative Analysis of Six Communities
Page Range: 443 – 460
This research investigates the outcomes of local social movements through a comparative analysis of superstore siting controversies. Data were generated by qualitative case studies of six attempts by local social movement organizations to prevent the siting of a Wal-Mart superstore in their communities. A comparison of the cases reveals that the SMOs were most likely to succeed when they produced evidence of widespread opposition, framed the issue broadly, received backing from the media, did not have to contend with a counter social movement organization, and benefited from blunders by Wal-Mart. It is suggested that these five factors can be generalized to help explain the outcomes of other local social movements. It is suggested further that the first three of these factors combine in a mutually reinforcing fashion to enable a small SMO to expand its influence and thereby increase its ability to prevail against a more powerful target.
Amenta, Edwin, Kathleen Dunleavy, and Mary Bernstein. 1994. "Stolen Thunder? Huey Long's "Share Our Wealth," Political Mediation, and the Second New Deal." American Sociological Review 59:678-702.
Amenta, Edwin and Michael P. Young. 1999. "Making an Impact: Conceptual and Methodological Implications of the Collective Goods Criterion." Pp. 22-41 in How Social Movements Matter, Marco Giugni, Doug McAdam, and Charles Tilly, eds. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Beaumont, Constance E. 1994. How Superstore Sprawl Can Harm Communities and What Citizens Can Do About It. Washington, DC: National Trust for Historic Preservation.
Benford, Robert D. and David A. Snow. 2000. "Framing Processes and Social Movements: An Overview and Assessment." Annual Review of Sociology 26: 611-639.
Bonanno, Alessandro and Douglas H. Constance. 2000. "Mega Hog Farms in the Texas Panhandle Region: Corporate Actions and Local Resistance." Research in Social Movements, Conflict and Change 22: 83-110.
Burstein, Paul. 1998. "Bringing the Public Back In: Should Sociologists Consider the Impact of Public Opinion on Public Policy?" Social Forces 77(1): 27-62.
Burstein, Paul. 1999. "Social Movements and Public Policy." Pp. 3-21 in How Social Movements Matter, Marco Giugni, Doug McAdam, and Charles Tilly, eds. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Burstein, Paul, Rachel L. Einwohner, and Jocelyn A. Hollander. 1995. "The Success of Political Movements: A Bargaining Perspective." Pp. 275-295 in The Politics of Social Protest, J. Craig Jenkins and Bert Klandermans, eds. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Burstein, Paul and April Linton. 2002. "The Impact of Political Parties, Interest Groups, and Social Movement Organizations on Public Policy: Some Recent Evidence and Theoretical Concerns." Social Forces 81(2): 381-408.
Cable, Sherry and Beth Degutis. 1997. "Movement Outcomes and Dimensions of Social Change: The Multiple Effects of Local Mobilizations." Current Sociology 45(3): 121-135.
Carroll, William K. and R.S. Ratner. 1999. "Media Strategies and Political Protests: A Comparative Study of Social Movements." Canadian Journal of Sociology 24(1): 1-34.
Cress, Daniel M. and David A. Snow. 2000. "The Outcomes of Homeless Mobilization: The Influence of Organization, Disruption, Political Mediation, and Framing." American Journal of Sociology 105(4): 1063-1104.
Earl, Jennifer. 2000. "Methods, Movements, and Outcomes." Research in Social Movements, Conflicts and Change. 22: 3-25.
Evans/McDonough Company Inc. n.d. "Research Report: Wal-Mart Proposal, Eureka and Humboldt County." Wal-Mart file, Eureka Department of Community Development.
Furuseth, Owen J. and Janet O'Callaghan. 1991. "Community Response to a Municipal Waste Incinerator: NIMBY or Neighbor?" Landscape and Urban Planning 21 (3): 163-71.
Gaffin, Dennis. 1997. "Offending and Defending US Rural Place: The Mega-Dump Battle in Western New York." Human Organization 56(30): 275-285.
Gamson, William A. 1975. The Strategy of Social Protest. Homewood, IL: Dorsey.
Gamson, William A. 1990. The Strategy of Social Protest 2nd ed. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
Gamson, William, and Gadi Wolfsfeld. 1993. "Movements and Media as Interacting Systems." Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 528: 114-127.
Giugni, Marco G. 1998. "Was It Worth the Effort? The Outcomes and Consequences of Social Movements." Annual Review of Sociology 24: 371-93.
Giugni, Marco G. 1999. "How Social Movements Matter: Past Research, Present Problems, Future Developments." Pp. xiii-xxxiii in How Social Movements Matter, Marco Giugni, Doug McAdam, and Charles Tilly, eds. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Gordon, Cynthia, and James M. Jasper. 1996. "Overcoming the ‘Nimby’ Label: Rhetorical and Organizational Links for Local Protestors." Research in Social Movements, Conflicts and Change 19: 159-181.
Harding, Alan. 1995. "Elite Theory and Growth Machines." Pp. 35-53 in Theories of Urban Politics, David Judge, Gerry Stoker, and Harold Wolman, eds. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
Hazarian, Tony. 1996. "Wal-Mart Alters Point Fosdick Store Look." Peninsula Gateway, April 17, 1996.
Hedström, Peter and Richard Swedberg, eds. 1998. Social Mechanisms: An Analytical Approach to Social Theory. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Jasper, James M. and Jane Poulsen. 1993. "Fighting Back: Vulnerabilities, Blunders, and Counter-mobilization by the Targets in Three Animal Rights Campaigns." Sociological Forum 8(4): 639-657.
Jenkins, J. Craig and Charles Perrow. 1977. "Insurgency of the Powerless: Farm Worker Movements (1946-1972)." American Sociological Review 42: 249-268.
Jonas, Andrew E.G., and David Wilson, eds. 1999. The Urban Growth Machine: Critical Perspectives Two Decades Later. Albany: State Univeristy of New York Press
Kane, Melinda. 2003. "Social Movement Policy Success: Decriminalizing State Sodomy Laws, 1969-1998." Mobilization 8(3): 313-334.
Kearney, Richard C. and Ande A. Smith. 1994. "The Low-Level Radioactive Waste Siting Process in Connecticut: Anatomy of a Failure." Policy Studies Journal 22(4): 617-30.
Kitschelt, Herbert P. 1986. "Political Opportunity Structures and Political Protest: Anti-Nuclear Movements in Four Democracies." British Journal of Political Science 16: 57-85.
Kurtz, Hilda E. 2002. "The Politics of Environmental Justice as the Politics of Scale: St. James Parish, Louisiana, and the Shintech Siting Controversy." Pp. 249-273 in Geographies of Power, Andrew Herod and Melissa W. Wright, eds. Malden, MA: Blackwell.
Leong, Andrew. 1996-1996. "The Struggle over Parcel C: How Boston's Chinatown Won a Victory in the Fight Against Institutional Expansion and Environmental Racism." Amerasia Journal 21(3): 99-119.
Lo, Clarence. 1982. "Countermovements and Conservative Movements in the Contemporary U.S." Annual Review of Sociology 8: 107-134.
Logan, John R. and Harvey L. Molotch. 1987. Urban Fortunes. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Meyer, David. S. and Suzanne Staggenborg. 1996. "Movements, Countermovements, and the Structure of Political Opportunity." American Journal of Sociology 101(6): 1628-1660.
Mill, John Stuart. 1851. A Method of Logic. 3rd ed. London: J.W. Parker.
Mobert, Mark. 2001. "Co-Opting Justice: Transformation of a Multiracial Environmental Coalition in Southern Alabama." Human Organization 60: 166-177.
Molotch, Harvey. 1977. "Media and Movements." Pp. 71-93 in The Dynamics of Social Movements, M. Zald and J. McCarthy, eds. Cambridge, MA: Winthrop Publishers.
Molotch, Harvey. 1988. "Strategies and Constraints of Growth Elites." Pp. 25-47 in Business Elites and Urban Development, Scott Cummings, ed. Albany: State University of New York Press.
Murphree, David W., Stuart A. Wright, and Helen Rose Ebaugh. 1996. "Toxic Waste Siting and Community Resistance: How Cooptation of Local Citizen Opposition Failed." Sociological Perspectives 39(4): 447-463.
Norman, Al. 2004. The Case Against Wal-Mart. Atlantic City, NJ: Raphel Marketing.
North, Peter. 1998. "‘Save our Solsbury!’: The Anatomy of an Anti-Roads Protest." Environmental Politics 7(3): 1-25.
Oliver, Pamela. 2002. "Mechanisms of Contention." Mobilization 8(1): 119-122.
Ortega, Bob. 1998. In Sam We Trust. New York: Random House.
Peninsula Neighborhood Association. 1995. "Wal-Mart Is Not a Done Deal." Political advertisement. The Peninsula Gateway, November 15, 1995.
Quinn, Bill. 2000. How Wal-Mart is Destroying America (and the world) and What You Can Do About It 2nd ed. Berkeley, CA: Ten Speed Press.
Ragin, Charles C. 1987. The Comparative Method. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Ritzer, George. 2004. The Globalization of Nothing. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Ross, Tom and Ken Kaplan. 1995. "Wal-Mart is OK, But the Valley Avenue Site Is Inappropriate." Daily News, April 24, 1995.
Rucht, Dieter. 2002. "Mobilization Against Large Techno-Industrial Projects: A Comparative Perspective." Mobilization 7(1): 79-95.
Schumaker, Paul D. 1975. "Policy Responsiveness to Protest-Group Demands." Journal of Politics 37:488-521.
Shemtov, Ronit. 1999. "Taking Ownership of Environmental Problems: How Local NIMBY Groups Expand Their Goals." Mobilization 4(1): 91-106.
Simmons, James and Nancy Stark. 1993. "Backyard Protest: Emergence, Expansion, and Persistence of a Local Hazardous Waste Controversy." Policy Studies Journal 21(3): 470-91.
Soule, Sarah A. and Susan Olzak. 2004. "When Do Movements Matter? The Politics of Contingency and the Equal Rights Amendment." American Sociological Review 69(4): 473-497.
Stilwell, Neil. 1994. "Alliance Plans Dec. 8 Town Meeting on Sprawl." Petoskey News-Review, November 30, 1994.
Stone, Kenneth. 1996. Competing with the Retail Giants: How to Survive in the New Retail Landscape. New York: John Wiley.
Times-Standard (Eureka, CA). 1999. "No on J a Vote for Progress, Fair Play." August 24, 1999.
U.S. Census Bureau. 1990. 1990 Census of Population. Washington DC: US GPO.
Wal-Mart. 2005. Annual Report.
Walsh, Edward J., Rex Warland, and C. Clayton Smith. 1997. Don't Burn It Here: Grassroots Challenges to Trash Incinerators. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press.
Zald, Mayer N. and Bert Useem. 1987. "Movement and Countermovement Interaction: Mobilization, Tactics, and State Involvement." Pp. 247-72 in Social Movements in an Organizational Society, Mayer N. Zald and John D. McCarthy, eds. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books.