Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 11 Jan 2008
"More Than A March in a Circle": Transgressive Protests and the Limits of Negotiated Management
"More Than A March in a Circle": Transgressive Protests and the Limits of Negotiated Management
and
Page Range: 341 – 357
We examine how tactical innovations introduced by transgressive protesters during the Seattle cycle of protests contributed to the end of a long, relatively stable period of détente between police and protesters in the United States. Case studies of the demonstrations staged by the AFL-CIO and the Direct Action Network (DAN) during the 1999 WTO protests are used to reveal the divergent capacity of the negotiated management style of policing protest to control contained and transgressive protesters. We argue that the transgressive protesters' tactics, organizational structure, and decision-making processes all frustrated police attempts to control their demonstrations and contributed to DAN's ability to shut down the opening day of the WTO. We conclude by developing a framework for understanding how police responded in subsequent protests using what we describe as "strategic incapacitation" and by proposing research questions about the impact of this style of policing on subsequent protests in the U.S. and other Western democracies.
ACLU. 2000. "Out of Control: Seattle's Flawed Response to Protests Against the World Trade Organization." American Civil Liberties Union Washington State Office, Seattle. Retrieved September 17, 2007 http://new.aclu-wa.org
ACLU. 2007. "No Real Threat: The Pentagon's Secret Database on Peaceful Protests." American Civil Liberties Union National Office, New York. Retrieved September 1, 2007 http://www.aclu.org/pdfs/safefree/spyfiles_norealthreat_20070117.pdf
Adams, Jason. 2000. Interview by WTO History Project. Harry Bridges Center for Labor Studies, University of Washington. Retrieved November 15, 2001 http://depts.washington.edu/wtohist
AFL-CIO. 2006. "AFL-CIO, About Us." Retrieved October 1, 2006. http://www.aflcio.org/aboutus
Almeida, Paul, D., and Mark I. Lichbach. 2003. "To the Internet, from the Internet: Comparative Media Coverage of Transnational Protests." Mobilization 8(3): 249-272.
Andrews, Kenneth, and Bob Edwards. 2005. "The Structure of Local Environmentalism." Mobilization 10(2): 213-234.
Auguirre, Rosalinda. 2000. Interview by author Patrick Gillham, November 29. Seattle, WA.
Barbee, Lynn. 2000. Interview by author Patrick Gillham, November 29. Seattle, WA.
Barkan, Steven. 1984. "Legal Control of the Southern Civil Rights Movement." American Sociological Review 49:552-565.
Baskin. Martha. 2000. Interview by WTO History Project. Harry Bridges Center for Labor Studies, University of Washington. Retrieved November 15, 2001 http://depts.washington.edu/wtohist
Beasley, Norman, Thomas Graham, and Carl Holmberg. 2000 "Justice Department Civil Disorder Initiatives Addresses Police Training Gap." The Police Chief LXVII(10): 113-122.
Boghosian, Heidi. 2004. The Assault on Free Speech, Public Assembly, and Dissent: A National Lawyers Guild Report on Government Violations of First Amendment Rights in the United States. Great Barrington, MA: The North River Press
Boshra, Basem, and Kevin Dougherty. 2001. "Activists Turned Back at Border: ‘It's Hypocritical." National Post, April 17, archived by Common Dreams. Retrieved September 12, 2007 http://www.commondreams.org/cgi-bin/print.cgi?file=/headlines01/0417-02.htm
Branch, Taylor. 1998. Pillars of Fire. New York, NY: Simon and Schuster.
Brand, Karl-Werner. 1999. "Dialectics of Institutionalization: The Transformation of the Environmental Movement in Germany," Pp. 35-58 in Environmental Movements: Local, National, and Global, edited by Christopher Rootes. London: Frank Cass.
Burton, Dick. 2000. Interview by WTO History Project. Harry Bridges Center for Labor Studies, University of Washington. Retrieved September 23, 2006 http://depts.washington.edu/wtohist
Cabrera, Luis. 2000. "Police Radio Traffic Shows Police Overmatched from the Start of the WTO." Associated Press. February 24.
Carter, Mike, David Postman, Steve Miletich, Susan Gilmore, and James V. Grimaldi. 1999. "Unrest Even at the Top During Riots." Seattle Times, p. A1.
Chaggi-Starr, Ali. 2000. "Relevant Culture and Strategic Anarchism: Hidden Weapons of Mass Uprisings." Pp. 55-56 in Voices From the WTO: An Anthology of Writings from the People who Shut Down the World Trade Organization, edited by Stephanie Guilloud. Olympia, WA: Evergreen State College Bookstore.
Chase, Eric. 2000. "One Wobbly Account: My Brief Account of the First 2 days of Protest." Pp. 31-33 in Voices From the WTO: An Anthology of Writings from the People who Shut Down the World Trade Organization, edited by Stephanie Guilloud. Olympia, WA: Evergreen State College Bookstore.
Chesters, Graeme, and Ian Welsh. 2004. "Rebel Colours: ‘Framing’ in Global Social Movements." The Sociological Review 52(3): 314-335.
Cockburn, Alexander, Jeffrey. St. Clair, and Allan Sekula. 2000. 5 Days That Shook the World. London: Verso.
Cook, Rebecca. 1999. "Police Crack Down on WTO Demonstrators." Associated Press. December 1.
Crass, Chris. 2000. "Shutting Down the WTO and Opening Up a World of Possibilities." Pp. 49-50 in Voices From the WTO: An Anthology of Writings from the People who Shut Down the World Trade Organization, edited by Stephanie Guilloud. Olympia, WA: Evergreen State College Bookstore.
DAN Action Packet. 1999. Resist the WTO-Seattle 1999- Mass Nonviolent Direct Action Packet. Distributed at DAN Convergence Center, 420 Denny Way, Seattle Washington, November 21-December 3.
della Porta, Donatella, Abby Peterson, and Herbert Reiter, eds. 2006. The Policing of Transnational Protest. London: Ashgate Publishing.
della Porta, Donatella, and Herbert Reiter, eds. 1998. Policing Protest. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Dolan, Michael. 2000. Interview by WTO History Project. Harry Bridges Center for Labor Studies, University of Washington. Retrieved November 16, 2001 http://depts.washington.edu/wtohist
Dolan, Michael. 2001. Phone interview by author Patrick Gillham, November 20.
Doucet, Marc G. 2005. "Territoriality and the Democratic Paradox: The Hemispheric Social Alliance and Its Alternatives for the Americas." Contemporary Political Theory 4(3): 275-295.
Drake, John, and Gerald Mizejewski. 2000. "D.C. Police Arrest Hundreds, Then Free Many." Washington Times. April 16:C1.
Dunphy, Steven. 1999. "We're Ready for Anything, Officials Say." The Seattle Times. November 10: B1.
Dwyer, Lynn E. 1983. "Structure and Strategy in the Antinuclear Movement." Pp. 148-161 in Social Movements of the Sixties and Seventies, edited by Jo Freeman. New York: Longman Inc.
Edwards, Bob, and Sam Marullo. 1995. "Organizational Mortality in a Declining Social Movement: The Demise of Peace Movement Organizations in the End of the Cold War Era." American Sociological Review 60(6): 908-927.
Edwards, Bob, and John McCarthy. 2004. "Strategy Matters: The Contingent Value of Social Capital in the Survival of Local Social Movement Organizations." Social Forces 83(2): 621-651.
Epstein, Barbara. 1991. Political Protest and Cultural Revolution: Nonviolent Direct Action in the 1970s and 1980s. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
Ericson, Richard V., and Kevin D. Haggerty. 1997. Policing the Risk Society. New York: Oxford University Press.
Feldman, Rich. 2000. Interview by WTO History Project. Harry Bridges Center for Labor Studies, University of Washington. Retrieved September 15, 2006 http://depts.washington.edu/wtohist
Fisher, William. 2001. Interview by author John Noakes, May 31. Philadelphia, PA.
Fisher, Dana R., Kevin Stanley, David Berman, and Gina Neff. 2005. "How Do Organizations Matter? Mobilization and Support for Participants at Five Globalization Protests." Social Problems 52: 102-121.
Gainer, Terrance. 2001. Interview by author John Noakes, July 3. Washington, DC.
Gamson, William. 1975. The Strategy of Social Protest. Homewood, IL: Dorsey.
Gillham, Patrick F. 2003. "Mobilizing for Global Justice: Social Movement Organization Involvement in Three Contentious Episodes, 1999-2001." Ph.D. dissertation, Department of Sociology, University of Colorado, Boulder, CO.
Gillham, Patrick F., and Bob Edwards, 2003. "Global Justice Protesters Respond to the September 11th Terrorist Attacks: The Impact of an Intentional Disaster on Demonstrations in Washington, D.C.". Pp. 483-520 in Beyond September 11th: An Account of Post-Disaster Research, edited by Jacquelyn L. Monday. Natural Hazards Research and Applications Information Center, Public Entity Risk Institute, and Institute for Civil Infrastructure Systems, Special Publication No. 39. Boulder, CO: Natural Hazards Research and Applications Information Center, University of Colorado
Gillham, Patrick, and Gary T. Marx. 2000. "Complexity and Irony in Policing and Protesting: The World Trade Organization in Seattle." Social Justice 27(2):212-236.
Gillham, Patrick, and Gary T. Marx. 2003. "Irony in Protest and Policing: The WTO in Seattle." Pp. 61-74 in Representing Resistance: Media, Civil Disobedience, and the Global Justice Movement, edited by Andy Opel and Donnalyn Pompper. Westport, CT: Praeger.
Goold, Benjamin J. 2004. CCTV and Policing: Public Area Surveillance and Police Practices in Britain New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Harris, Linda, and Craig McCoy. 2001. "Protester Convicted of 1 Charge, Acquitted on 3." Philadelphia Inquirer. March 18:E2.
IMC. 2001. "Official IMC Seattle Statement on the ‘FBI Raid.’" Seattle Independent Media Center Spokescouncil, achieved at nettime.org. Retrieved September 10, 2007 http://www.nettime.org/Lists-Archives/nettime-1-0105/msg00051.html
Kaufman, L.A. 2002. "A Short History of Radical Renewal." Pp. 35-40 in From Act Up to the WTO: Urban Protest and Community Building in the Era of Globalization, edited by Benjamin Shepard and Ronald Hayduk. New York: Verso.
Kerner, Otto. 1968. Report on the National Advisory Commission on Civil Disorders. New York: Dutton.
Lacayo, Richard. 1999. "Rage Against the Machine." Time Magazine. December 13. Retrieved September 17, 2007 http://www.time.com
Lojowsky, Mac. 2000. "Comes a Time." Pp. 12-16 in Voices From the WTO: An Anthology of Writings from the People who Shut Down the World Trade Organization, edited by Stephanie Guilloud. Olympia, WA: Evergreen State College Bookstore.
Mackay, David. 2006. "Changing Nature of Public-Space CCTV." Security Journal 19(2): 128-142.
Marx, Gary T. 1988. "External Efforts to Damage or Facilitate Social Movements: Some Patterns, Explanations, Outcomes, and Complications." Pp. 94-125 in Dynamics of Social Movements: Resource Mobilization, Social Control, and Tactics, edited by Mayer N. Zald and John. D. McCarthy. Lanham, MD: University Press of America.
McPhail, Clark, David Schweingruber, and John McCarthy. 1998. "Policing Protest in the United States: 1960-1995." Pp. 49-69 in Policing Protest, edited by Donatella della Porta and Herbert Reiter. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
McPhail, Clark, and John McCarthy. 2005. "Protests, Protest Repression, and Their Interaction." Pp. 3-32 in Repression and Mobilization, edited by Christian Davenport, Hank Johnston, and Carol Mueller. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Murphy, Gillian, and Steven Pfaff. 2005. "Thinking Locally, Acting Globally? What the Seattle WTO Protests Tell Us about the Global Justice Movement." Political Power and Social Theory 17:. 151-176.
National Lawyer's Guild. 2000. "Waging War on Dissent." A Report by the Seattle National Lawyers Guild WTO Legal Group, archived by Rat Haus Reality Press. Retrieved September 17, 2007 http://www.ratical.org/co-globalize/NLG-REPORT.pdf
Neale, Jonathan. 2002. You Are G8, We are 6 Billion. London: Vision Paperbacks.
Noakes, John, and Patrick F. Gillham. 2006. "Aspects of the ‘New Penology’ in the Police Response to Major Political Protests in the United States, 1999-2000," Pp. 97-116 in The Policing of Transnational Protest, edited by Donatella della Porta, Abby Peterson and Herbert Reiter. London: Ashgate Publishing.
Noakes, John, Brian Klocke, and Patrick F. Gillham. 2005. "Whose Streets? Police and Protesters Struggle over Space in Washington, DC, 29-30 September, 2001." Policing and Society 15(3): 235-254.
Norris, Clive, and Gary Armstrong. 1999. The Maximum Surveillance Society: The Rise of CCTV. Berg Publishers.
O'Brien, Vinnie. 2000. Interview by WTO History Project. Harry Bridges Center for Labor Studies, University of Washington. Retrieved September 15, 2006 http://depts.washington.edu/wtohist
Oliver, Pamela, and Myers, Daniel J. 2003. "The Coevolution of Social Movements" Mobilization 8: 1-24.
Piven, Frances Fox, and Richard Cloward. 1978. Poor People's Movements. New York: Vintage.
Polizei Mechklenburg-Vorpommern. 2006a. "Contract to Build the Technical Barrier Awarded." Press Release 06. Retrieved June 7, 2007 http://www.polizei.mvnet.de
Polizei Mechklenburg-Vorpommern. 2006b. "Building Construction of the Technical Barrier Will Start at the End of January." Press Release 07. Retrieved June 7, 2007 http://www.polizei.mvnet.de
Rootes, Christopher. 1999a. "The Transformation of Environmental Activism: Activists, Organizations, and Policy Making." Innovation 12:155-173.
Rootes, Christopher. 1999b. Environmental Movements: Local, National, and Global. London: Frank Cass.
Rootes, Christopher. 2005. "Rethinking Social Movements: Structure, Meaning and Emotion." British Journal of Sociology 56(4): 670-671.
Sasson, Saskia. 2004. "Local Actors in Global Politics." Current Sociology 52(4): 649-670.
Schweingruber, David. 2000. "Mob Sociology and Escalated Force: Sociology's Contribution to Repressive Police Tactics." The Sociological Quarterly 41:371-389.
Scott, James C. 1985. Weapons of the Weak: Everyday Forms of Peasant Resistance. Yale University Press.
Scott, Tyree. 2000. Interview by WTO History Project. Harry Bridges Center for labor Studies, University of Washington. Retrieved September 15, 2006 http://depts.washington.edu/wtohist
Seattle City Council. 2000. "Report to the WTO Accountability Review Committee." Retrieved November 20, 2001 http://www.cityofseattle.net/wtocommittee
Seattle Police Department. 2000. "After Action Report, World Trade Organization Ministerial Conference, Nov 29-Dec 3, 1999." Retrieved November 10, 2001 http://www.cityofseattle.net/spd/SPDMainsite/wto/spdwtoaar.htm
Seattle Times Staff. 1999. "Schell Urges: Stay in Control." The Seattle Times. December 2: A1.
Shan, Han. 2000. Interview by WTO History Project. Harry Bridges Center for Labor Studies, University of Washington. Retrieved November 15, 2001 http://depts.washington.edu/wtohist
Shepard, Benjamin, and Ronald Hayduk, eds. 2002. From Act Up to the WTO: Urban Protest and Community Building in the Era of Globalization. New York: Verso.
Shukovsky, Paul. 2001. "FBI Raids Media Center." Seattle Post-Intelligencer. Retrieved September 10, 2007 http://seattlepi.nwsource.com
Slivka, Judd. 1999. "Summit Security a Work in Progress." Seattle Post-Intelligencer. October 1: A1.
Slobodzian, Joseph. 2001. "Puppet Factory, Pair Suing Phila. in Arrest." Philadelphia Inquirer, Jan. 23: B4.
Smith, Jackie. 2001. "Globalizing Resistance: The Battle of Seattle and the Future of Social Movements." Mobilization 6: 1-19.
Snow, David A. 2004. "Social Movements as Challenges to Authority: Resistance to an Emerging Hegemony." Pp. 3-25 in Authority in Contention, Research in Social Movements, Conflict and Change edited by Daniel. J. Meyers and Daniel. M. Cress. London/New York: Elsevier.
Solnit, David. 2000. Interview by WTO History Project. Harry Bridges Center for Labor Studies, University of Washington. Retrieved November 15, 2001 http://depts.washington.edu/wtohist
Staggenborg, Suzanne. 1988. The Pro-Choice Movement. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
Starhawk. 2001. "Passcode Redwood: Keeping Repression in Perspective." Znet Commentary, December 21. Retrieved September 10, 2007 www.zmag.org/Sustainers/content/2001-12/21starhawk.cfm
Starhawk. 2000. "How We Really Shut Down the WTO." Pp. 47-48 in Voices From the WTO: An Anthology of Writings from the People who Shut Down the World Trade Organization, edited by Stephanie Guilloud. Olympia, WA: Evergreen State College Bookstore.
Starr, Amory. 2000. "Urgent: Report from Seattle." Starr Action Reports. Retrieved August 8, 2006 http://www.trabal.org/texts/n30.html
Starr, Amory. 2005. Global Revolt: A Guide to the Movements Against Globalization. New York: Zed Books.
Stern, Robbie. 2000. Interview by WTO History Project. Harry Bridges Center for Labor Studies, University of Washington. Retrieved November 15, 2001 http://depts.washington.edu/wtohist
Tarrow, Sidney. 2005. "The Dualities of Transnational Contention: ‘Two Activist Solitudes’ or a New World Altogether?" Mobilization 10(1): 53-72.
Thomas, Janet. 2000. The Battle in Seattle: The Story Behind the WTO Demonstrations. Golden, CO: Fulcrum.
Tilly, Charles. 2000. "Spaces of Contention." Mobilization 5: 135-159.
Vitale, Alex. 2005. "From Negotiated Management to Command and Control: How the New York Police Department Polices Protests." Policing and Society 15: 283-304.
Waddington, P. A. J. 1994. Liberty and Order: Public Order Policing in a Capital City. London: UCL Press.
Waddington, P. A. J. 1998. "Controlling Protest in Contemporary Historical and Comparative Perspective." Pp. 117-140 in Policing Protest, edited by Donatella della Porta and Herbert Reiter. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Waddington, P. A. J. 1999. Policing Citizens. London: UCL Press.
Whitman, Bradford. 2001. Interview by author John Noakes, May 31. Philadelphia, PA.
Wilder, Verlene. 2000a. Interview by WTO History Project. Harry Bridges Center for Labor Studies, University of Washington. Retrieved November 15, 2001 http://depts.washington.edu/wtohist
Wilder, Verlene. 2000b. "Interview by author Patrick Gillham, November 28." Seattle WA.
Wood, Lesley. 2003. "Organizing against the Occupation: U.S. and Canadian Anti-War Activists Speak Out." Social Movement Studies 3(2): 241-257.
WSLC Report. 1999. "AFL-CIO's WTO Rally and March: Massive, Loud and Peaceful." Washington State Labor Council Reports Online, News for November 29-December 3. Retrieved September 10, 2006 http://www.wslc.org/reports/12-3-99.htm
WTO History Project Archives. 2000. Harry Bridges Center for Labor Studies, University of Washington. http://depts.washington.edu/wtohist