Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 16 Apr 2010
The Contextual Dependence of Movement Outcomes: A Simplified Meta-Analysis
The Contextual Dependence of Movement Outcomes: A Simplified Meta-Analysis
Page Range: 433 – 448
This article investigates the empirical evidence for the statement that the impact of social movement organizations (SMOs) and interest groups on policy making is dependent on public opinion and the political system. A meta-analysis of articles published in eleven sociology and political science journals from 1990 to 2007 is used to test two hypotheses: 1) when public opinion is taken into account, SMOs and interest groups have no direct effect on policy; 2) the existence of a democratic regime is a necessary precondition for finding any policy impact of SMOs and interest groups. Results show that taking account of public opinion does not generally make any difference in the finding of direct effects. However, the role of public opinion varies across the measures of organizational resources and activity. I also find that a democratic regime is not a necessary precondition for the impact of SMOs and interest groups on public policy, but show that a direct effect of interest organizations is less likely to be found in the studies that take account of political regime.
Agnone, Jon. 2007. "Amplifying Public Opinion: The Policy Impact of the U.S. Environmental Movement." Social Forces 85(4): 1593-1620.
Almeida, Paul. 2003. "Opportunity Organizations and Threat-Induced Contention: Protest Waves in Authoritarian Settings." American Journal of Sociology 109(2): 345-400.
Alvarez, Michael R., Geoffrey Garrett, and Peter Lange. 1991. "Government Partisanship, Labor Organization, and Macroeconomic Performance." The American Political Science Review 85(2): 539-56.
Amenta, Edwin, Bruce Carruthers, and Yvonne Zylan, 1992. "A Hero for the Aged? The Townsend Movement, the Political Mediation Model, and U.S. Old-Age Policy, 1934-1950." American Journal of Sociology 98 (2):308-39.
Amenta, Edwin, Kathleen Dunleavy, and Mary Bernstein. 1994. "Stolen Thunder? Huey Long's ‘Share Our Wealth’, Political Mediation, and the Second New Deal." American Sociological Review 59: 678-702.
Amenta, Edwin, and Michael Young. 1999. "Democratic States and Social Movements: Theoretical Arguments and Hypotheses." Social Problems 46(2): 153-168.
Amenta, Edwin, and Neal Caren. 2004. "The Legislative, Organizational, and Beneficiary Consequences of State Oriented Challengers." Pp. 461-89 in The Blackwell Companion to Social Movements, edited by David A. Snow, Sarah A. Soule, and Hanspeter Kriesi. London: Blackwell.
Amenta, Edwin 2005. ‘Political Contexts, Challenger Strategies, and Mobilization: Explaining the Impact of the Townsend Plan.’ In Routing the Opposition, edited by David S. Meyer, Valerie Jenness and Helen Ingram. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Amenta, Edwin, Neal Caren, and Sheera Joy Olasky. 2005. "Age for Leisure? Political Mediation and the Impact of the Pension Movement on US Old-Age Policy." American Sociological Review 70(3): 516-38.
Andrews, Kenneth. 2001. "Social Movements and Policy Implementation: The Mississippi Civil Rights Movement and the War on Poverty, 1965-1971." American Sociological Review 66: 71-95.
Andrews, Kenneth. 2004. Freedom Is a Constant Struggle: The Mississippi Civil Rights Movement and Its Legacy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Andrews, Kenneth, and Bob Edwards. 2004. "Advocacy Organizations in the U.S. Political Process." Annual Review of Sociology 30: 479-506.
Berry, Jeffrey M. 1997. The Interest Group Society, 3rd edition. Boston: Little, Brown.
Beyers, Jan, Rainer Eising, and William Maloney. 2008. "Researching Interest Group Politics in Europe and Elsewhere: Much We Study, Little We Know?" West European Politics 31(6): 1103-28.
Boudreau, Vincent. 1996. "Northern Theory, Southern Protest: Opportunity Structure Analysis in Cross-National Perspective." Mobilization 1(2): 175-189.
Burstein, Paul. 1998. "Bringing the Public Back In: Should Sociologists Consider the Impact of Public Opinion on Public Policy?" Social Forces 77: 27-62.
Burstein, Paul. 2006a. "Why Estimates of the Impact of Public Opinion on Public Policy Are Too High: Empirical and Theoretical Implications." Social Forces 84(4): 2273-89.
Burstein, Paul. 2006b. "Review on Giugni's Social Protest and Policy Change: Ecology, Antinuclear, and Peace Movements in Comparative Perspective." American Journal of Sociology 111(5): 1581-83.
Burstein, Paul, and Elizabeth C. Hirsh. 2007. "Interest Organizations, Information, and Policy Innovation in the U.S. Congress." Sociological Forum 22(2): 174-199.
Burstein, Paul, and April Linton. 2002. "The Impact of Political Parties, Interest Groups and Social Movement Organization on Public Policy: Some Recent Evidence and Theoretical Concerns." Social Forces 81(2): 380-408.
Cornwall, Marie, Brayden. G. King, Elizabeth M. Legerski, Eric. C. Dahlin, and Kendra S. Schiffman. 2007. "Signals or Mixed Signals: Why Opportunities for Mobilization are not Opportunities for Policy Reform." Mobilization 12(3): 239-54.
Cress, Daniel, and David Snow. 2000. "The Outcomes of Homeless Mobilization: The Influence of Organization, Disruption, Political Mediation, and Framing." American Journal of Sociology 105(4): 1063-1104.
Dahl, Robert. 1989. Democracy and Its Critics. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Davenport, Christian. 2007. "State Repression and Political Order." Annual Review of Political Science 10(1): 1-23.
Davis, Christina L. 2004. "International Institutions and Issue Linkage: Building Support for Agricultural Trade Liberalization." American Political Science Review 98: 153-169.
Desai, Raj M., Anders Olofsgård, and Tarik M. Yousef. 2007. "The Logic of Authoritarian Bargains: A Test of a Structural Model." Brookings Global Economy and Development Working Paper No. 3.
Druckman, James N., and Lawrence Jacobs. 2006. "Lumpers and Splitters: The Public Opinion Information that Politicians Collect and Use." Public Opinion Quarterly 70(4): 453-76.
Dür, Andreas. 2008a. "Measuring Interest Group Influence in the EU: A Note on Methodology." European Union Politics 9(4): 559-76.
Dür, Andreas. 2008b. "Interest Groups in the European Union: How Powerful Are They?" West European Politics 31(6): 1212-30.
Earl, Jennifer. 2000. "Methods, Movements and Outcomes: Methodological Difficulties in the Study of Extra-Movement Outcomes." Research in Social Movements, Conflicts and Change 22: 3-25.
Fording, Richard C. 1997. "The Conditional Effect of Violence as a Political Tactic: Mass Insurgency, Welfare Generosity, and Electoral Context in the American States." American Journal of Political Science 41(1): 1-29.
Fording, Richard C. 2001. "The Political Response to Black Insurgency: A Critical Test of Competing Theories of the State." The American Political Science Review 95(1): 115-130.
Gamson, William A. 1975. The Strategy of Social Protest. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing.
Giugni, Marco. 1998. "Was It Worth the Effort? The Outcomes and Consequences of Social Movements." Annual Review of Sociology 24: 371-93.
Giugni, Marco. 2004. Social Protest and Policy Change: Ecology, Antinuclear, and Peace Movements in Comparative Perspective. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
Giugni, Marco. 2007. "Useless Protest? A Time-Series Analysis of the Policy Outcomes of Ecology, Antinuclear, and Peace Movements in the United States, 1977-1995. Mobilization 12(1): 53-77.
Grossmann, Gene M., and Elhanan Helpman. 2001. Special Interest Politics. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Grossmann, Matt. "The Organization of Factions: Interest Mobilization and the Group Theory of Politics." Public Organization Review 6(2): 107-124.
Hunter, John E., and Frank L. Schmidt. 2004. Methods of Meta-Analysis: Correcting Error Bias in Research Findings. Newbury Park: Sage Publications.
Jenness, Valerie. 1999. "Managing Differences and Making Legislation: Social Movements and the Racialization, Sexualization, and Gendering of Federal Hate Crime Law in the U.S., 1985-1998." Social Problems 46(4): 548-71.
Kane, Melinda. 2003. "Social Movement Policy Success: Decriminalizing State Sodomy Laws, 1969-1998." Mobilization 8(3): 313 - 334.
Kane, Melinda. 2007. "Timing Matters: Shifts in the Causal Determinants of Sodomy Law Decriminalization, 1961-1998." Social Problems 54(2): 211-39.
Keller, Jonathan W., and Yi Edward Yang. 2008. "Leadership Style, Decision Context, and the Poliheuristic Theory of Decision Making: An Experimental Analysis." Journal of Conflict Resolution 52(5): 687-712.
King, Brayden G., Keith G. Bentele, and Sarah A. Soule. 2007. "Protest and Policymaking: Explaining Fluctuation in Congressional Attention to Rights Issues, 1960-1986." Social Forces 86(1): 137-163.
Kitschelt, Herbert. 1986. "Political Opportunity Structures and Political Protest: Anti-Nuclear Movement in Four Democracies." British Journal of Political Science 16(1): 57-85.
Kolb, Felix. 2007. Protest and Opportunities: The Political Outcomes of Social Movement. New York: Campus Press.
Kono, Daniel Y. 2008. "Does Public Opinion Affect Trade Policy?" Business and Politics 10(2): 2.
Kriesi, Hanspeter, Ruud Koopmans, Jan Willem Duyvendak, and Marco Giugni. 1995. New Social Movements in Western Europe. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Lang, Kurt, and Gladys Engel Lang. 2008. "Advocacy: Alternative Expressions of Public Opinion." pp.41-52 in The Sage Handbook of Public Opinion Research, edited by Wolfgang Donsbach and Michael W. Traugott. Newbury Park: Sage Publications.
Lipsky, Michael. 1968. "Protest as Political Resource." American Political Science Review 62(4): 1144-58.
Lohmann, Susanne. 1993. "A Signaling Model of Informative and Manipulative Political Action." American Political Science Review 87: 319-33.
Lowry, Robert C., and Matthew Potoski. 2004. "Organized Interests and the Politics of Federal Discretionary Grants." The Journal of Politics 66: 513-33.
Luders, Joseph. 2006. "The Economics of Movement Success: Business Responses to Civil Rights Mobilization." American Journal of Sociology 111(4): 963-98.
McAdam, Doug, and Yang Su. 2002. "The War at Home: Antiwar Protests and Congressional Voting, 1965-1973." American Sociological Review 67: 696-721.
Meyer, David S. 2004. "Protest and Political Opportunities." Annual Review of Sociology 30: 125-145.
Meyer, David S., and Debra C. Minkoff. 2004. "Conceptualizing Political Opportunity." Social Forces 82(4): 1457-92.
Munck, Gerardo L., and Jay Verkuilen. 2002. "Conceptualizing and Measuring Democracy: Evaluating Alternative Indices." Comparative Political Studies 35: 5-34.
Page, Benjamin and Ian Shapiro. 1983. "Effects of Public Opinion on Policy." American Political Science Review 77: 175-190.
Piven, Frances, and Richard Cloward. 1979. Poor People's Movements. New York: Vintage Books.
Sabatier, Paul, ed. 2007. Theories of the Policy Process. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Santoro, Wayne A. 2002. "The Civil Rights Movement's Struggle for Fair Employment: A ‘Dramatic Events-Conventional Politics’ Model." Social Forces 81(1): 177-206.
Santoro, Wayne A. 2008. "The Civil Rights Movement and the Right to Vote: Black Protest, Segregationist Violence and the Audience." Social Forces 86: 1391-1411.
Schock, Kurt. 2005. Unarmed Insurrections: People Power Movements in Nondemocracies. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Soule, Sarah A. 2004. "Going to the Chapel? Same-Sex Marriage Bans in the United States, 1973-2000." Social Problems 51(4): 453-77.
Soule, Sarah A., and Brayden G. King. 2006. "The Stages of the Policy Process and the Equal Rights Amendment, 1972-1982." American Journal of Sociology 111(6): 1871-1909.
Soule, Sarah A., and Susan Olzak. 2004. "When do Movements Matter? The Politics of Contingency and the Equal Rights Amendment." American Sociological Review 69(4): 473-97.
Tarrow, Sidney. 1994. Power in Movement: Social Movements and Contentious Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Uba, Katrin. 2005. "Political Protest and Policy Change: The Direct Impacts of Indian Antiprivatization Mobilizations, 1990-2003." Mobilization 10(3): 383-96.
Werum, Regina. 1999. "Elite Control in State and Nation: Racial Inequalities in Vocational Funding in North Carolina, Georgia, and Mississippi, 1918-1936." Social Forces 78(1): 145-186.