Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 16 Apr 2010
The Policy Impact of Social Movements: A Replication Through Qualitative Comparative Analysis
The Policy Impact of Social Movements: A Replication Through Qualitative Comparative Analysis
and
Page Range: 467 – 484
This article reanalyzes the data of a previous study on the policy impact of antinuclear, ecology, and peace movements in three countries with the aim of replicating its findings. Our goal is to see whether using a different analytical technique will yield similar results. The previous study used a regression approach to time-series analysis. Here, we use qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) to analyze the previous study's data. Specifically, we test the two main hypotheses based on the joint-effect model of social movement outcomes: (1) that the policy impact of social movements is conditioned by the presence of powerful allies within the institutional arenas, by the presence of a favorable public opinion, and/or by both factors simultaneously; and (2) that social movements are more likely to have policy impacts when they address issues and policy domains of low saliency. In addition, we compare the policy impact of social movements across countries. Our analysis confirms to a large extent the findings of the earlier time-series analysis, namely, the strong explanatory power of the jointeffect model of social movement outcomes and the varying impact of different movements on public policy.
Amenta, Edwin. 2006. When Movements Matter. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Amenta, Edwin. 2005. "Political Contexts, Challenger Strategies, and Mobilization: Explaining the Impact of the Townsend Plan." Pp. 29-64 in Routing the Opposition, edited by David S. Meyer, Valerie Jenness, and Helen Ingram. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Amenta, Edwin, and Neil Caren. 2004. "The Legislative, Organizational, and Beneficiary Consequences of State-Oriented Challenges." Pp. 462-488 in The Blackwell Companion to Social Movements, edited by David Snow, Sarah Soule, and Hanspeter Kriesi. Cambridge: Blackwell.
Amenta, Edwin, Neal Caren, and Sheera Joy Olasky. 2005. "Age for Leisure? Political Mediation and the Impact of the Pension Movement on U.S. Old-Age Policy." American Sociological Review 70: 516-38.
Amenta, Edwin, Bruce G. Carruthers, and Yvonne Zylan. 1992. "A Hero for the Aged? The Townsend Movement, the Political Mediation Model, and U.S. Old-Age Policy, 1934-1950." American Journal of Sociology 98: 308-39.
Amenta, Edwin, Kathleen Dunleavy, and Mary Bernstein. 1994. "Stolen Thunder? Huey Long's Share Our Wealth, Political Mediation, and the Second New Deal." American Sociological Review 59: 678-702.
Baumgartner, Frank R., and Bryan D. Jones. 1993. Agendas and Instability in American Politics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Barkan, Steven E. 1984. "Legal Control of the Southern Civil Rights Movement." American Sociological Review 49: 552-65.
Becker, Howard S. 1998. Tricks of the Trade. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Burstein, Paul. 1999. "Social Movements and Public Policy." Pp. 3-21 in How Social Movements Matter, edited by Marco Giugni, Doug McAdam, and Charles Tilly. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Burstein, Paul. 1998a [1985]. Discrimination, Jobs, and Politics, 2nd edition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Burstein, Paul. 1998b. "Bringing the Public Back In: Should Sociologists Consider the Impact of Public Opinion on Public Policy?" Social Forces 77: 27-62.
Burstein, Paul, and William Freudenburg. 1978. "Changing Public Policy: The Impact of Public Opinion, Anti-War Demonstrations and War Costs on Senate Voting on Vietnam War Motions." American Journal of Sociology 84: 99-112.
Burstein, Paul, and April Linton. 2002. "The Impact of Political Parties, Interest Groups, and Social Movement Organizations on Public Policy: Some Recent Evidence and Theoretical Concerns." Social Forces 81: 380-408.
Caren, Neal, and Aaron Panofsky. 2005. "TQCA: A Technique for Adding Temporality to QCA." Sociological Methods and Research 34: 147-172.
Costain, Anne N., and Steven Majstorovic. 1994. "Congress, Social Movements and Public Opinion: Multiple Origins of Women's Rights Legislation." Political Research Quarterly 47: 111-135.
Cress, Daniel M., and David A. Snow. 2000. "The Outcomes of Homeless Mobilization: The Influence of Organization, Disruption, Political Mediation, and Framing." American Journal of Sociology 105: 1063-1104.
De Meur, Gisele, Benoit Rihoux, and Sakura Yamasaki. 2009. "Addressing the Critiques of QCA." Pp. 147-165 in Configurational Comparative Methods, edited by Benoit Rihoux and Charles C. Ragin. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Diani, Mario. 1994. "The Conflict Over Nuclear Energy in Italy." Pp. 201-231 in States and Antinuclear Movements, edited by Helena Flam. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Duyvendak, Jan Willem. 1995. The Power of Politics. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Flam, Helena (ed). 1994. States and Antinuclear Movements. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
Frey, Scott, Thomas Dietz, and Linda Kalof. 1992. "Characteristics of Successful American Protest Groups: Another Look at Gamson's Strategy of Social Protest." American Journal of Sociology 98: 368-87.
Gamson, William A. 1990 [1975]. The Strategy of Social Protest, 2nd edition. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing.
Giugni, Marco. 2007. "Useless Protest? A Time-series Analysis of the Policy Outcomes of Ecology, Antinuclear, and Peace Movements in the United States, 1975-1995." Mobilization 12: 101-116.
Giugni, Marco. 2004. Social Protest and Policy Change. Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield.
Giugni, Marco. 2001. "L'impact des mouvements écologistes, antinucléaires et pacifistes sur les politiques publiques: Le cas des Etats-Unis, de l'Italie et de la Suisse, 1975-1995." Revue Française de Sociologie 42: 641-68.
Giugni, Marco. 1998. "Was it Worth the Effort? The Outcomes and Consequences of Social Movements." Annual Review of Sociology 24: 371-93.
Goldstone, Jack A. 1980. "The Weakness of Organization: A New Look at Gamson's The Strategy of Social Protest." American Journal of Sociology 85: 1017-42.
Haltiner, Karl W., Kurt R. Spillmann, and Andreas Wenger. 1999. Sicherheit 1999: Aussen-, Sicherheits- und Verteidigungspolitische Meinungsbildung im Trend. Zürich: ETH Zürich.
Jenkins, J. Craig, and Charles Perrow. 1977. "The Insurgency of the Powerless: Farm Workers' Movements (1946-1972)." American Sociological Review 42: 249-68.
Kane, Melinda D. 2003. "Social Movement Policy Success: Decriminalizing State Sodomy Laws, 1969-1998." Mobilization 8: 313-34.
Kingdon, John W. 1984. Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies. Boston: Little, Brown.
Kitschelt, Herbert. 1986. "Political Opportunity Structures and Political Protest: Antinuclear Movements in Four Democracies." British Journal of Political Science 16: 57-85.
Koopmans, Ruud, and Dieter Rucht 2002. "Protest Event Analysis." Pp. 231-259 in Methods of Social Movement Research, edited by Bert Klandermans and Suzanne Staggenborg. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Kriesi, Hanspeter, Ruud Koopmans, Jan Willem Duyvendak, and Marco G. Giugni. 1995. New Social Movements in Western Europe. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Laakso, Markku and Rein Taagepera. 1979. "Effective Number of Parties: A Measure with Application to West Europe." Comparative Political Studies 12: 3-27.
Lipsky, Michael. 1968. "Protest as a Political Resource." American Political Science Review 62: 1144-58.
Mackie, John Leslie. 1974. The Cement of the Universe: A Study of Causation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
McAdam, Doug. 1999 [1982]. Political Process and the Development of Black Insurgency, 1930-1970. 2nd edition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
McAdam, Doug, and Yang Su. 2002. "The War at Home: Antiwar Protests and Congressional Voting, 1965 to 1973." American Sociological Review 67: 696-721.
McCammon, Holly J., Karen E. Campbell, Ellen M. Granberg, and Christine Mowery. 2001. "How Movements Win: Gendered Opportunity Structures and U.S. Women's Movements, 1866 to 1919." American Sociological Review 66: 49-70.
Mill, John Stuart. 1967. A System of Logic. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Mirowsky, John, and Catherine Ross. 1981. "Protest Group Success: The Impact of Group Characteristics, Social Control, and Context." Sociological Focus 14: 177-192.
Przeworski, Adam, and Henry Teune. 1970. The Logic of Comparative Social Inquiry. Malabar, FL: Robert E. Krieger Publishing.
Ragin, Charles C. 2003. "Making Comparative Analysis Count." COMPASSS Working Paper 2003-10. Retrieved August 2009 ( http://www.compasss.org/WP.htm
Ragin, Charles C. 2000. Fuzzy-Set Social Science. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Ragin, Charles C. 1987. The Comparative Method. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Ragin, Charles, C., and Sarah Ilene Strand. 2008. "Using Qualitative Comparative Analysis to Study Causal Order: Comment on Caren and Panofsky (2005)." Sociological Methods and Research 36: 431-41.
Rihoux, Benoit. 2003. "Bridging the Gap between the Qualitative and Quantitative Worlds? A Retrospective and Prospective View on Qualitative Comparative Analysis." Field Methods 15: 351-65.
Rihoux, Benoit, and Charles C. Ragin (eds). 2009. Configurational Comparative Methods. Thousand Oaks: Sage.
Rüdig, Wolfgang. 1990. Antinuclear Movements. Harlow: Longman.
Sabatier, Paul A., and Hanc C. Jenkins-Smith. 1993. Policy Change and Learning. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
Schumaker, Paul D. 1978. "The Scope of Political Conflict and the Effectiveness of Constraints in Contemporary Urban Protest." Sociological Quarterly 19: 168-184.
Schumaker, Paul D. 1975. "Policy Responsiveness to Protest-Group Demands." Journal of Politics 37: 488-521.
Soule, Sarah A., and Susan Olzak. 2004. "When Do Movements Matter? The Politics of Contingency and the Equal Rights Amendment." American Sociological Review 69: 473-97.
Stanley, Harold W., and Richard G. Niemi. 1995. Vital Statistics on American Politics, 5th edition. Washington, DC: CQ Press.
Steedly, Homer R., and John W. Foley. 1979. "The Success of Protest Groups: Multivariate Analyses." Social Science Research 8: 1-15.
Tarrow, Sidney. 1998 [1994]. Power in Movement, 2nd edition Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Tarrow, Sidney. 1993. "Social Protest and Policy Reform: May 1968 and the Loi d'Orientation in France." Comparative Political Studies 25: 579-607.
Wunsch, Guillaume. 1988. Causal Theory and Causal Modeling. Leuven: Leuven University Press.