Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 24 Jul 2014
The Dilemmas of Social Movement Identity and the Case of the Voice of the Faithful
The Dilemmas of Social Movement Identity and the Case of the Voice of the Faithful
and
Page Range: 209 – 227
This article focuses on the dilemmic nature of identity for challengers within organizations and on their emergent responses. It is based on ethnographic research of one affiliate of Voice of the Faithful, a group of Catholics that formed in the wake of the clergy sexual abuse crisis. The abiding faith of the group and their commitment to change the church created a dilemma that encapsulates the central question of this article: how do challengers pursuing change of an institution balance commitment and critique, mainstream membership and otherness? Internal challengers manage these dilemmas by rescripting existing stories and telling novel ones to navigate group boundaries and formulate new understandings of their individual and collective pasts, presents, and futures. We trace the ways in which challengers work through contradictions and ambiguity in their emergent identities. This provides an opportunity to explore the existential dimensions of collective identity and focus on the processual nature of storytelling.
Ammerman, Nancy T. 2003. "Religious Identities and Religious Institutions." Pp. 207-224 in Handbook of the Sociology of Religion, edited by Michelle Dillon. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Ammerman, Nancy T. 2005a. "Studying Everyday Religion: Challenges for the Future." Pp. 219-38 in Everyday Religion: Observing Modern Religious Lives, edited by Nancy T. Ammerman. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Ammerman, Nancy T. 2005b. Pillars of Faith: American Congregations and Their Practices. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Armstrong, Elizabeth A., and Suzanna M. Crage. 2006. "Movements and Memory: The Making of the Stonewall Myth." American Sociological Review 71(5): 724-51.
Bender, Courtney. 2003. Heaven's Kitchen: Living Religion at God's Love We Deliver. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Bernstein, Mary. 2005. "Identity Politics." Annual Review of Sociology 31: 47-74.
Bernstein, Mary. 2008. "The Analytic Dimensions of Identity: A Political Identity Framework." Pp. 277-301 in Identity Work in Social Movements, edited by Jo Reger, Rachel L. Einwohner, and Daniel J. Myers. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Blee, Kathleen. 2012. Democracy in the Making: How Activist Groups Form. New York: Oxford University Press.
Brubaker, Rogers, and Frederick Cooper. 2000. "Beyond ‘Identity.’" Theory and Society 29(1): 1-47.
Bruce, Tricia Colleen. 2011. Faithful Revolution: How Voice of the Faithful Is Changing the Church. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Crossley, Nick. 2004. "Phenomenology, Structuralism and History." Theoria 103: 88-121.
D'Antonio, William D., and Anthony Pogerelc, eds. 2007. Voices of the Faithful: Loyal Catholics Striving for Change. New York: Herder & Herder.
Davis, Joseph E. 2002. "Narrative and Social Movements: The Power of Stories." Pp. 3-29 in Stories of Change: Narrative and Social Movements, edited by Joseph E. Davis. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Dillon, Michele. 1999. Catholic Identity: Balancing Reason, Faith, and Power. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Ecklund, Elaine H. 2005. "Different Identity Accounts for Catholic Women." Review of Religious Research 47(2): 135-149.
Edelman, Lauren, Howard S. Erlanger, and John Lande. 1993. "Internal Dispute Resolution: The Transformation of Civil Rights in the Workplace." Law & Society Review 27(3): 497-534.
Einwohner, Rachel L., Jo Reger, and Daniel J. Meyers. 2008. "Introduction: Identity Work, Sameness and Difference in Social Movements." Pp. 1-17 in Identity Work in Social Movements, edited by Jo Reger, Rachel L. Einwohner, and Daniel J. Meyers. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Eliasoph, Nina, and Paul Lichterman. 2003. "Culture in Interaction." American Journal of Sociology 108(4): 735-94.
Emirbayer, Mustafa, and Ann Mische. 1998. "What is Agency?" American Journal of Sociology 102(4): 962-1023.
Engel, David M., and Frank W. Munger. 2003. Rights of Inclusion: Law and Identity in the Life Stories of Americans with Disabilities. Chicago University of Chicago Press.
Ewick, Patricia, and Susan S. Silbey. 1995. "Subversive Stories and Hegemonic Tales: Toward a Sociology of Narrative." Law & Society Review 29(2): 197-226.
Ewick, Patricia, and Susan S. Silbey. 1998. The Common Place of Law: Stories of Everyday Life. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Ewick, Patricia, and Susan S. Silbey. 2003. "Narrating Social Structure: Stories of Resistance to Legal Authority." American Journal of Sociology 111(6): 1718-61.
Fine, Gary Alan. 2010. "The Sociology of the Local: Action and its Publics." Sociological Theory 28(4): 355-76.
Fraser, Nancy. 2003. "Rethinking Recognition: Overcoming Displacement and Reification in Cultural Politics." Pp. 21-32 in Recognition Struggles and Social Movements: Contested Identities, Agency and Power, edited by Barbara Hobson. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Fraser, Nancy. 2000. "Rethinking Recognition." New Left Review 3: 107-120.
Gamson, Joshua. 1995. "Must Identity Movements Self Destruct? A Queer Dilemma." Social Problems 42(3): 390-407.
Giddens, Anthony. 1984. The Constitution of Society. Cambridge, UK: Polity.
Greeley, Andrew. 1991. The Catholic Myth: the Behavior and Beliefs of American Catholics. New York: Collier.
Gutierrez, Betzaluz, Jennifer Howard-Grenville, and Maureen A. Scully. 2010. "The Faithful Rise Up: Split Identification and an Unlikely Change in Effort." Academy of Management Journal 53(4): 673-99.
Hill Collins, Patricia. 1986. "Learning from the Outsider Within: The Sociological Significance of Black Feminist Thought." Social Problems. 33(6): S14-S32.
Holland, Dorothy, Gretchen Fox, and Vinci Daro. 2008. "Social Movements and Collective Identity: A Decentered, Dialogic View." Anthropological Quarterly 81(1): 95-126.
Jasper, James M. 1997. The Art of Moral Protest: Culture, Biography, and Creativity in Social Movements. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Katz, Jack. 1988. Seductions of Crime: Moral and Sensual Attractions in Doing Evil. New York: Basic.
Katzenstein, Mary Fainsod. 1998. Faithful and Fearless: Moving Feminist Protest Inside the Church and the Military. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Kretschmer, Kelsy. 2009. "Contested Loyalties: Dissident Identity Organizations, Institutions, and Social Movements." Sociological Perspectives 52(4): 433-54.
Kurtz, Sharon. 2002. Workplace Justice: Organizing Multi-Identity Movements. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Leach, Darcy K. 2009. "An Elusive ‘We’: Antidogmatism, Democratic Practice, and the Contradictory Identity of the German Autonomen." American Behavioral Scientist 52(7): 1042-68.
Leitz, Lisa. 2011. "Oppositional Identities: The Military Peace Movement's Challenge to Pro-Iraq War Frames." Social Problems 58(2): 235-56.
Leming, Laura M. 2006. "Church as Contested Terrain: Voice of the Faithful and Religious Agency." Review of Religious Research 48(1): 56-71.
Lichterman, Paul. 1999. "Talking Identity in the Public Sphere: Broad Visions and Small Spaces in Sexual Identity Politics." Theory and Society 28(1): 101-141.
McCann, Michael W. 1994. Rights at Work: Pay Equity and the Politics of Legal Mobilization. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
McCann, Michael W. 2006. "Law and Social Movements: Contemporary Perspectives." Annual Review of Law and Social Science 2: 17-38.
Melucci, Alberto. 1996. Challenging Codes: Collective Action in the Information Age. Cambridge: UK: Cambridge University Press.
Minow, Martha. 1997. Not Only for Myself: Identity, Politics, and the Law. New York: New Press.
Mische, Ann. 2008. Partisan Publics: Communication and Contention Across Brazilian Youth Networks. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Muller, James. 2004. Keep the Faith, Change the Church: The Battle by Catholics for the Soul of Their Church. Emmaus, PA: Rodale.
Nepstad, Sharon Erickson. 2001. "Creating Transnational Solidarity: The Use of Narrative in the U.S.-Central American Peace Movement." Mobilization 6(1): 21-36.
Nepstad, Sharon Erickson. 2004a. "Persistent Resistance: Commitment and Community in the Plowshares Movement." Social Problems 51(1): 43-60.
Nepstad, Sharon Erickson. 2004b. Convictions of the Soul: Religion, Culture, and Agency in the Central American Solidarity Movement. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Norgaard, Kari Marie. 2006. "‘People Want to Protect Themselves a Little Bit’: Emotions, Denial, and Social Movement Nonparticipation." Sociological Inquiry 76(3): 72-96.
Owens, Lynn. 2008. Cracking Under Pressure: Narrating the Decline of the Amsterdam Squatters' Movement. University Park: The Pennsylvania State University Press.
Pedriana, Nicolas. 2006. "From Protective to Equal Treatment: Legal Framing Processes and Transformation of the Women's Movement in the 1960s." American Journal of Sociology 111(6): 1718-61.
Polletta, Francesca. 1998. "‘It Was Like A Fever…’ Narrative and Identity in Social Protest." Social Problems 45(2): 137-159.
Polletta, Francesca. 2002. "Plotting Protest: Mobilizing Stories in the 1960 Student Sit-Ins." Pp. 31-35 in Stories of Change: Narrative and Social Movements, edited by Joseph E. Davis. Albany, NY: SUNY Press.
Polletta, Francesca. 2006. It Was Like A Fever: Storytelling in Protest and Politics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Polletta, Francesca, and James Jasper. 2001. "Collective Identity and Social Movements." Annual Review of Sociology 27: 283-305.
Raeburn, Nicole A. 2004. Changing Corporate America from Inside Out: Lesbian and Gay Workplace Rights. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Schwalbe, Michael L., and Douglas Mason Schrock. 1996. "Identity As Group Process." Advances in Group Processes 13: 113-147.
Shotter, John. 1992. "Bakhtin and Billig: Monological Versus Dialogical Practices." American Behavioral Scientist 36: 8-21.
Smith, Jonathan, Maria Jarman, and Michael Osborn. 1999. "Doing Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis." Pp. 18-40 in Qualitative Health Psychology: Theory and Methods, edited by Michael Murray and Kerry Chamberlain. London: Sage.
Smithey, Lee A. 2009. "Social Movement Strategy, Tactics, and Collective Identity." Sociology Compass 3(4): 658-71.
Snow, David A., and Doug McAdam. 2000. "Identity Work Processes in the Context of Social Movements: Clarifying the Identity/Movement Nexus." Pp. 41-67 in Self, Identity, and Social Movements, edited by Sheldon Stryker, Timothy J. Owens, and Robert W. White. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Somers, Margaret R. 1994. "The Narrative Constitution of Identity: A Relational and Network Approach" Theory and Society 23(5): 605-49.
Taylor, Verta, and Nancy Whittier. 1992. "Collective Identity in Social Movement Communities." Pp. 104-129 in Frontiers in Social Movement Theory, edited by Aldon Morris and Carol McClung Mueller. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
Valocchi, Stephen. 2008. "The Importance of Being ‘We’: Collective Identity and the Mobilizing Work of Progressive Activists in Hartford, Connecticut." Mobilization 14(1): 65-84.
Wetherall, Margaret. 2011. "Introduction: Negotiating Liveable Lives—Identity in Contemporary Britain." Pp. 1-18 in Identity in the 21st Century: New Trends in Changing Times, edited by Margaret Wetherall. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan.
Whittier, Nancy. 1995. Feminist Generations: The Persistence of the Radical Women's Movement. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
Yukich, Grace. 2010. "Boundary Work in Inclusive Religious Groups: Constructing Identity at the New York Catholic Worker." Sociology of Religion 71(2): 172-196.