Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
 | 
Online Publication Date: 31 Mar 2020

CRISIS AND POLICY CHANGE: HIV/AIDS AND SYRINGE SERVICES IN CALIFORNIA*

Page Range: 71 – 92
DOI: 10.17813/1086-671X-25-1-71
Save
Download PDF

Mobilization researchers have recently sought mechanisms that produce movement outcomes by reshaping relations among groups involved in contentious politics. Environmental mechanisms, which externally influence conditions of contention, are particularly salient in health-related movements where biological and ecological factors are implicated. In this article I conceptualize an environmental mechanism associated with collective responses to epidemic and eruptive social problems: the mechanism of crisis—an unforeseen and rapidly spreading threat that (1) motivates transgressive contention by those threatened, (2) elevates challengers through alliances with powerful groups that share their perspective, and (3) facilitates policy change by temporarily undermining officials' credibility. I illustrate this mechanism in the case of syringe services programs for HIV prevention in California. Using archives, newspapers, and indepth interviews, I show that the inconsistent spread of syringe services followed the development and deterioration of an HIV/AIDS-related crisis. This mechanism also explains resurgent attention to syringe services amid the ongoing overdose crisis.

Copyright: 2020 Mobilization: An International Quarterly 2020

Contributor Notes

* I thank Kyle Barbour, Alex Barnard, Lindsay Berkowitz, Ricky Bluthenthal, Boroka Bó, Megan Comfort, Véronique Irwin, Leah Jacobs, Andrew Jaeger, Leslie Knight, Alex Kral, Jennifer Lorvick, Miriam McQuade, Cassandra Miracle, Santiago Molina, Christopher Muller, Alessandra Ross, Maria-Fatima Santos, Kristen Schilt, Josh Seim, Loïc Wacquant, Margaret Weir, Lynn Wenger, Brandie Wilson, numerous discussants at UC Berkeley, and the anonymous reviewers and editor of Mobilization for their advice and feedback. I am grateful to the staff at the Gay and Lesbian Historical Society, San Francisco Public Library, UC San Francisco Archives and Special Collections, and to my interview participants. This research was supported in part by a Graduate Research Fellowship from the National Science Foundation.

PhD candidate in sociology, University of California, Berkeley.

Contact address: davidshowalter@berkeley.edu.
  • Download PDF