Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
 | Online Publication Date: 21 Feb 2006
Hinges in Collective Action: Strategic Innovation in The Pittston Coal Strike
Hinges in Collective Action: Strategic Innovation in The Pittston Coal Strike
Page Range: 179 – 199
Employing the case of the United Mine Workers of America (UMWA) 1989-1990 strike against the Pittston Coal Group, this article examines the UMWA collective action repertoire and the possibility of its transformation during the strike. The concepts of modularity and collective action repertoire highlight the UMWA's experimentation with different collective actions, its importation of actions new to the union, and its elimination of unsuccessful or high-risk elements that had been part of the union's conventional strike practices. This article introduces the concept of a "hinge in collective action" as a way of understanding changes in the UMWA's change in repertoire, and concludes with reflections on directions for future research.
New York Times. 1985b. "Judge Bans Picketing in Coal Miners' Strike" (March 18): A14.
New York Times. 1989b. "Pittston Dividend First in 6 Years" (May 6): L35.
New York Times. 1989c. "Thousands Walk Off Mining Jobs, and Threaten a Wider Coal Strike" (June 13): A25.
New York Times. 1989d. "Wildcat Strike Continues Despite Order" (June 15): A23.
New York Times. 1989e. "Wildcat Strike Being Linked to Union" (June 17): I:7:4.
New York Times. 1989f. "Governor Again Invites Coal Strike Leaders to Talk" (June 27): A15.
New York Times. 1989g. "Miners' Union Cooling-Off Period Starts With Gunfire, and Explosion" (July 11): I:14:1.
New York Times. 1989a. "U.S. Mediation Is Accepted in 28-Day Coal Strike" (May 3): A-23.
New York Times. 1985e. "Coal Truck Driver Slain; Killing Linked to Strike" (May 30): A14.
New York Times. 1985f. "Company Chief Demands End to Coal Field Strife" (May 31): A14.
New York Times. 1985d. "Six-Month Old Coal Miners' Strike Grows Bitter" (April 2): A10.
New York Times. 1985c. "Judge Levies $200,000 Fine Against Striking Mine Union" (March 28): A23.
New York Times. 1989h. "UMW Is Fined Again" (July 28): I:9:3.
Green, James R. 1996. "'Tying the Knot of Solidarity': The Pittston Strike of 1989-1990." Pp. 513-544 in The United Mine Workers of America: A Model of Industrial Solidarity?, John H. M. Laslett, ed. University Park, Pa.: Pennsylvania State University Press.
Hinds, Michael deCourcy. 1989. "Bitter Coal Strike May Be at End, but Ripples From Dispute Are Widely Felt." New York Times (December 23): 17.
Honacker, Hobart. 1997. Legislative Assistant to Mr. Stump. Telephone interview by author. February 18.
Hudson, Marty. 1993. Interview with author. Washington, D.C.: UMWA. September 2.
Johnson, Tom. 1989. "Work, Family, Union: Pittston Attacks a Way of Life." UMW Journal, 100 (7): 5-9.
Knapp, Dennis R. 1989. "Order Clarifying Temporary Injunction." UMW Journal, 100 (10): 20.
Kopple, Barbara, and Bill Davis. 1990. Out of Darkness: The Mine Workers' Story. Labor History, and Cultural Foundation.
Laslett, John H. M., ed. 1996. The United Mine Workers of America: A Model of Industrial Solidarity? University Park, Pa.: Pennsylvania State University Press.
Miles, Gregory L., with Cynthia Green. 1985. "The Coalfield Heavyweight Who's Going the Distance." Business Week (October 21): 123-128.
New York Times. 1985a. "Nonunion Truckers Smash Striking Miners' Roadblock" (March 15): B12.
Rabin, Robert J., Eileen Silverstein, and George Schatzki. 1995. Statutory Supplement to Labor, and Employment Law: Problems, Cases, and Materials in the Law of Work (2nd ed.). St. Paul, Minn.: West Publishing.
Ravo, Nick. 1989. "Greenwich Politely Bored at Miners." New York Times (October 7): 26.
Register-Herald. 1989. "$13 Million Drop Reported in UMW Strike Fund." (November 22).
Render, Edwin R. 1995. "Comparative Role of the Judiciary in the 1984-85 British Coal Strike, and the 1989 Pittston Coal Strike." Comparative Labor Law Journal, Spring, 16 (3): 317-357.
Roberts, Cecil. 1995. Interview with author. Charleston, West Virginia: UMWA Region 2 Headquarters. 23 June.
Rochon, Thomas. 1988. Mobilizing for Peace. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press.
Schattschneider, E. E. 1975. The Semisovereign People. Hinsdale, Ill.: Dryden Press.
Norris, Floyd. 1989. "Taking a Strike to the Board Room." New York Times (May 5): D1-D6.
New York Times. 1989i. "Labor Secretary Gets 2 Sides To Meet in Long Coal Strike" October 14:9.
Serrin, William. 1985a. "Miners' Strike in 9th Month Is a Test of Union Strategy." New York Times (June 9): A26.
Serrin, William. 1985b. "The Violent Coal Strike." New York Times (June 24): A16.
Stump, Jackie. 1997. Telephone interview with author. February 21.
Tarrow, Sidney. 1994. Power in Movement. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
UMWA. n.d. "The Conflict between the Pittston Company, and the United Mine Workers of America." Washington, D.C.: United Mine Workers of America.
UMW Journal. 1989. "Camp Solidarity Alert." 100 (8): 20.
Yancey, Dwayne. 1990. "Thunder in the Coalfields." Special Report of the Roanoke Times, and World-News (April 29).
Appalshop, Inc. 1986 "Mine War on Blackberry Creek." 1986. Video. Whitesburg, KY.
Sessions, Jim, and Fran Ansley. 1993. "Singing Across Dark Spaces: The Union/Community Takeover of Pittston's Moss 3 Plant." Pp. 195-223 in Fighting Back in Appalachia: Traditions of Resistance, and Change, Stephen L. Fisher, ed. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Tilly, Charles. 1978. From Mobilization to Revolution. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Tilly, Charles. 1984. "Social Movements, and National Politics." Pp. 297-317 in State-Making, and Social Movements: Essays in History, and Theory, Charles Bright, and Susan Harding, eds. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Tilly Charles. 1995. Popular Contention in Great Britain, 1758-1834. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Ayres, B. Drummond, Jr. 1989a. "Coal Miners' Strike Hits Feelings That Go Deep." New York Times (April 27): A16.
Ayres, B. Drummond, Jr. 1989b. "Thousands Back in Coal Mines; West Virginia Pickets March On." New York Times (July 18): I:12:3.
Ayres, B. Drummond, Jr. 1989c. "Tension Easing, but Miners' Strike Against Pittston Goes On." New York Times (November 26): 30.
Beckwith, Karen. 1998a. "Gender Frames, and Collective Action: Configurations of Masculinity in the Pittston Coal Strike." Paper presented to the Departments of Political Science, and Sociology, the Pennsylvania State University, State College, Pa. April 30.
Beckwith, Karen. 1998b. "Strikes, and State Response: Collective Action, and Political Systems in Mining Strikes." Paper presented at the annual meetings of the American Political Science Association. Boston, MA.
Beckwith, Karen. 1998c. "Collective Identities of Class, and Gender: Working-Class Women in the Pittston Coal Strike." Political Psychology, 19 (1): 147-167.
Birecree, Adrienne M. 1996. "The Importance, and Implications of Women's Participation in the 1989-90 Pittston Coal Strike." Journal of Economic Issues, XXX (1), March: 187-210.
Burke, Eddie. 1990. "The UMWA/Pittston Strike: The Labor Movement's Experiment with Non-Violent Civil Disobedience." Unpublished paper prepared for the Samuel Gompers Union Leadership Award.
Burke, Eddie. 1995. Interview with author. Cambridge, Ohio. August 3.
Carroll, Gene. 1989a. "'We Have to Be Involved': Religions Leaders Condemn Pittston's 'Economic Violence.'" UMW Journal, 100 (9): 13-15.
Carroll, Gene. 1989b. "Camp Solidarity: Heart of the Pittston Strike." UMW Journal, 100 (10):15-17.
Clark, Paul F. 1996. "Legacy of Democratic Reform: The Trumka Administration, and the Challenge of the Eighties." Pp. 459-483 in The United Mine Workers of America: A Model of Industrial Solidarity? John H. M. Laslett, ed. University Park Pennsylvania State University Press.
Cleveland Plain Dealer. 1989. "Civilly disobedient miners" (April 30):2A.
Cox, Archibald, Derek Curtis Bok, Robert A. Gorman, and Mathew W. Finkin. 1996. Labor Law: Cases, and Materials (12th ed.). Westbury, New York: Foundation Press.
Couto, Richard. 1993. "The Memory of Miners, and the Conscience of Capital: Coal Miners' Strikes as Free Spaces." Pp. 165-194 in Fighting Back in Appalachia: Traditions of Resistance, and Change, Stephen L. Fisher, ed. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Evans, Sara M., and Harry C. Boyte. 1992. Free Spaces. Chicago University of Chicago Press.
Gold, Michael Evan. 1989. An Introduction to Labor Law. Ithaca, N.Y.: ILR Press.
Golden, Miriam A. 1997. Heroic Defeats: The Politics of Job Loss. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
McGlothlin, Donald A. 1989. "Important Notice." UMW Journal, 100 (9): 20.