Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
 | 
Online Publication Date: 21 Feb 2006

Social Movements in the Mexico City Airport Controversy: Globalization, Democracy, and the Power of Distance

and
Page Range: 279 – 293
DOI: 10.17813/maiq.9.3.866k48l6876gt317
Save
Download PDF

How did a relatively small group of uneducated peasants organize a movement to halt a huge national project to build a showcase airport outside Mexico City? This article applies the power of distance model, an analytic perspective for understanding social movement origins and successes based on an understanding of state-society relations, to the mobilization by indigenous peasants against the proposed Texcoco airport. The power of distance perspective focuses on relative distance or closeness of relations between the state and its citizens. Our findings indicate that, despite democratization in Mexico, the distance between local peasants and the newly elected Fox administration was widened by its neoliberal, globalizing focus, which partly explains the escalation of the anti-airport mobilization. On another dimension, peasants were able to bridge the distance between them and global human-rights networks using an indigenous rights frame and global communications media to bring new resources to bear and eventually force the Fox administration to withdraw the airport proposal.

Mendez, Enrique, and Carlos Camacho.2002. "SCT: hay otras alternativas para el nuevo aeropuerto. Analizan Montiel Rojas y su equipo la estrategia a seguir" La Jornada, August 2, 2002.

Morris, Aldon. 2000. "Reflections on Social Movement Theory: Criticisms and Proposals." Contemporary Sociology 29: 445-454.

Navarro, Bernardo and Alicia Ziccardi. 1995 Ciudad de México: Retos y Propuestas Para la Coordinación Metropolitana. Mexico: Universidad Autonoma Metropolitana.

Peattie, Lisa R. 1991. Planners and Protesters: Airport Opposition as Social Movement. Maryland: University of Maryland at College Park.

"Interacciones, posible nuevo agente financiero del aeropuerto," Retrieved April 27, 2002 from

"Interacciones, posible nuevo agente financiero del aeropuerto," Retrieved April 27, 2002 from

"Interacciones, posible nuevo agente financiero del aeropuerto," Retrieved April 27, 2002 from

"Interacciones, posible nuevo agente financiero del aeropuerto," Retrieved April 27, 2002 from

"Mexico Airport Controversy, Mexico City." 2001. Thursday, October 25, retrieved April 10, 2002 from the World Wide Web:

Rojas, Rosa. 2001. "Se manifiesta el Congreso Nacional Indigena contra el nuevo aeropuerto," La Jornada, November 3, Retrieved from

Mendez, Enrique, and Carlos Camacho. 2002. "Hidalgo mantiene su proyecto de terminal de carga." La Jornada, August 2.

Rivera, Maria. 2001. "Juego al gato y al raton con los asesores jurídicos de Fox," La Jornada, January 31, Política, p. 17.

Rosan, Christina. 2002. No Al Aeropuerto en Texcoco Regional Decision-Making and Community Countermobilization: The Siting of Mexico City's New Airport. Master Thesis, MIT Department of Urban Studies and Planning.

Sassen, Saskia. 1998. Globalization and Its Discontents. New York: The New Press.

Cerisola y Weber, Pedro. 2001. "Decisión del Gobierno Federal sobre la Ubicación del Nuevo Aeropuerto Intemacional de la Ciudad de México." Public statement October 22.

Alvarado, Rene Ramon, and Javier Salinas. 2001. "Crean ejiditarios fondo para amparo," La Jornada, November 3. Política, p. 14.

Alvarado, Rene Ramon, Javier Salinas, Silvia Chavez, and Matilde Perez. 2001. "Alcalde de Atenco, dispuesto dialogar con campesinos," La Jornada, November 6, Política, p. 20.

Alvarado, Rene Ramon, Javier Salinas, y Roberto Garduño. 2002. "Piden a Rosario Ibarra, Samuel Ruiz y Francisco Gallardo que participen como mediadores, Proponen los ejidatarios de Atenco instalar una mesa de negotiatión Desconocen al gobierno de Arturo Montiel; posible incursión policiaca esta madrugada," La Jornada, July 12.

Azuela, Antonio. 1989. La ciudad, la propiedad privada, y el derecho. Mexico City: El Colegio de Mexico.

Bureau of Economic and Business Affairs, U.S. State Department. Country Reports on Economic Policy and Trade Practices. February 2002. Retrieved May 12, 2002 from

Alvarado, Rene Ramon, Javier Salinas Cesareo, and Silvia Gonzalez, 2002. "Cientos de ejidatarios evitaron perforation del suelo en Texcoco," La Jornada, January 9, p. 14.

Ayuntamiento de Texcoco, 2001. "Carta al Presidente Fox del Ayuntamiento de Texcoco." November 6, 2001, La Jornada, p. 40.

Cerny, Philip G. 2000. "Globalization and The Changing Logic of Collective Action." Pp. 111-141 in Theory and Structure in International Political Economy, Charles Lipson and Benjamin J. Cohen eds. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Davis, Diane E. 1999. "The Power of Distance: Rethinking Social Movements in Latin America." Theory and Society 24 (4): 589-643.

Davis, Diane E.1994. Urban Leviathan: Mexico City in the Twentieth Century. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania: Temple University Press.

"Interacciones, posible nuevo agente financiero del aeropuerto," Retrieved April 27, 2002 from

"Interacciones, posible nuevo agente financiero del aeropuerto," Retrieved April 27, 2002 from

Cymet, David. 1992. From Ejido to Metropolis, Another Path: An Evaluation of Ejido Property Rights and Informal Land Development in Mexico City. New York: Peter Lang, American University Studies, Series XXI, Regional Studies, Vol. 6, p. 137.

Gobierno del Distrito Federal, Oficialía Mayor. 2000. La Ciudad de México Hoy. Bases Para Un Diagnostico: Los Limites Del Desarrollo Urbano Metropolitano. Mexico: Gobierno del Distrito Federal.

Goodwin, Jeff, and James Jasper. 1999. "Caught in a Winding, Snarling Vine: the Structural Bias of a Political Process Theory." Sociological Forum 14:27-53.

Susskind, Lawrence, and Jeffrey Cruikshank. 1991. "Breaking the Impasse." Pp. 31-54 in Confronting Regional Challenges: Approaches to LULUs, Growth, and Other Vexing Governance Problems, Joseph DiMento and LeRoy Graymer, eds. Cambridge MA: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy.

The World Bank. 2002. "Mexico Country Brief," retrieved May 13, 2002 from

Ziccardi, Alicia. 1998. Gobernabilidad y Participatión Ciudana en La Ciudad Capital. Mexico: Institute de Investigaciones Sociales UNAM.

  • Download PDF